Reviews for Alfredo's At the Inn Italian Restaurant in Mayfield, OH

We reserved my Grandma's 85th birthday party and omgosh the staff did not disappoint! I loved that there were reservation text... messages (it was a large party), and none of the staff ever dropped the ball. From first call to the end of the night this staffseriously did everything they could to make us comfortable. The food was great, the drinks when someone in our party wasn't into what they ordered the staff made up for it big time. We had 14 people our limit was 13 and yet they still accommodated.Fabulous experience and can't recommend them enough. Thank you Alfredo's! Read more

This is a restaurant attached to a hotel. While it is very clean, it just doesn't have that Italian restaurant feel. The food is... decent. I think it's a little pricey for what you get. The fettuccine isn't as thick & creamy as what I like. It's more on therunny, soupy side. The zucchini sticks are very good as an appetizer. The best dish that I had there was their Pizza Bianca. Adelicious spinach pizza with their garlic butter sauce. I believe what makes this place special is all the wonderful people whowork there. Everyone was so friendly & helpful. Read more

We were supposed to go somewhere else tonight and it was unexpectedly closed. We were very pleasantly surprised coming here... instead for the first time. Our server Salena was awesome! The food was awesome! And the atmosphere awesome! We will be makingthis a regular spot! Read more

Had some high hopes for the restaurant but left kinda disappointed. Loved mussels in a red sauce! Calamari were average. Too... many banana peppers on the plate and those weren’t any good tbh. Found a hair on my pizza ???? Our server was pretty nice andsuggested to fix it for us but we were just ready to go. Nope, not coming back. Read more

First time trying and it was good - it is adjacent to the Holiday Inn - I tried the Mussels - Stuffed artichokes (not really... stuffed just bread crumbs wasn't to pleased)- House salad - Chicken parmigiana - Chicken Marsala They have a happy hour that Iwill definitely check out Read more

Came with a party of 11. Food was pretty good overall. We really enjoyed the fried zucchini. Salad was fresh. It took 20+... minutes for anyone to visit our table (and that was with a reservation on a Monday night). Never received rolls. For those of usdrinking water, we were doing so out of these tiny 4-6 oz glasses with no ice. Read more

Everything was very fresh! We had two different types of sauce forthe mussels. I personally liked the red sauce better. Garlic... was good. PS, dipp your bread in the sauce you won't be disappointed! The food was really good too! Service was really good aswell! Read more

We had a bereavement luncheon for my mother. Impeccable service, friendly and kind staff and the food...UNBELIEVABLE!... Absolutely out of this world. I couldn't reccomend Alfrados, the price and working with Brooke more! Read more