Menu for Andy's Pizza Old Town in Alexandria, VA

We tried Andy?s for the first time tonight and wow this is great NY pizza. I loved the crust and real mutz. I also like that you... can order by the slice and if you?re feeling indecisive you can do 8 different slices or half and half pizza for a reasonableprice. I was also really impressed with how fast they had our pizza ready (less than 30 min). The staff were friendly and pickupwas easy. We?ll definitely be back for more. Read more

As a native NY?er, I was super excited to see a new pizza joint pop up so close to our home. There are not many good pizza spots... in the DMV area outside Wise Guys that offer great-tasting NY-style pizza. We ordered the Miller Time (vegan-style Margarita). First the ordering?we ordered online (easy) and we got a text saying our pizza was ready; however, when we went into Andy?s wewere advised the pizza was NOT ready and needed another 10 minutes. The place is clean inside with ample seating. Now for thepizza?they serve slices but they look like they were sitting on the counter all day and have what looks like a toaster to heatslices. I would recommend going with a whole pie. The pizza we ordered was great, and the crust was crunchy and super light andtasty ?I would just ask they put a little more sauce on their pies (see pic). The service?the staff was friendly and appeared tobe working hard to make good-tasting pies. Price-wise?pies are a bit more on the pricier side, but you get what you pay for andthe pizza is worth it in my opinion.\n\nLiving so close to this new spot, we will definitely return and try some other pies. Read more

Every downtown needs a local pizza shop like this. Crispy thin crust with this right amount of cheese and sauce. Good music and... vibes. Order by the slice or pie. Read more

Pizza is 5/5 the best! But unfortunately i had a pick up scheduled 11/4 6 pm that I ordered online 11/1, I came on time but they... didn?t have my order ready, it took a while to find my order in the system and I had to wait 20 minutes. Just disappointingcause I ordered pick up for a reason, not to wait. Also it would?ve been fine if it was a normal night pizza but I bought 3pizzas for a birthday party and everyone had to wait. Hopefully they fix their pre order system Read more

You can buy pizza by the slice or get a whole pie. And I opted for the later.\n\nI ordered the pepperoni special which was... generously packed with burrata cheese and hot honey.\n\nI?m so glad that there is a new pizza joint in town to make mynon-cooking days extra special Read more