Menu for Hickory Hill Ice Cream Stand in Baldwinsville, NY

Loved the coconut cream ice cream. Staff friendly and helpful.

Used to LOVE this place. Drove 20 min to go there for a Zombie sundae only find that they have changed their ice cream to that... cheap ice milk. It was terrible and no strawberries in my sundae . All I could taste was fake chocolate flavor. Ended up in thegarbage after a couple bites. Go back to the real ice cream or lose customers. Read more

This place would be 5 stars if the serving sizes were more consistent. Additionally, if they would take pride in the... comfortability of their guests and the appearance of the place by cleaning out all the dead bugs that are always on the orderingcounters as well as all the spiders and spider webs that are right above your head as you're ordering and waiting for your icecream. Read more

Good homemade ice cream flavors. Had the Snickers which was vanilla based with lots of chunks of Snickers bar...yummy! Also... tried the Lemon Cream...smooth lemony flavor...delicious. My only complaint was that there was only one person at the window fora while. Eventually, they opened the other window. The line was wat too long. Read more

They have lots of options. Including quite a few extra soft serve. I myself tried the orange flavored icecream. It was simply... wonderful. All I can say is come check it out and see for yourself. I think they do have sherbet too. Read more