Menu for Sal's Pizza Cedarburg in Cedarburg, WI

Sal's is now under the original management and wow, does it show, the taste of the pizza is just incredible. The past few years... when it was under a different owner it just didn't have any kick, but today I got the BBQ pork pizza and wow my taste buds wentcrazy. So much flavor and zest, they really did an amazing job reviving this place. I got to shake hands with Sal Jr which meanta lot to me as a customer. He is a very cordial, professional individual with a charming Brooklyn accent that makes the wholeexperience feel like you're at a genuine NYC pizzaria. In fact, it's even better. I will be frequenting here for lunch to buythe individual slices. It is so nice to have a locally owned, ala carte pizza place in town, make sure you support this familyrun, local business, they deserve every penny. Read more

Sal Jr is Back! Brooklyn Pizza in Wisconsin has arrived. Flawless Brooklyn Pizza, outstanding Calzone! You might walk right past... Sal's but I would urge anyone who wants a taste of a real Brooklyn NY pizza, stop in, grab a slice and enjoy. Read more

Extremely gracious staff to top off the great pizza. I always like pairing my pizza with wings and the ones I've had (twice now)... fell off of the bone. They make strombolis and calzones too. You should call ahead cause these bad boys take 20 minutes. Ihighly recommend the spinach feta! Read more

It is hit or miss when I have gone. Sometimes good. Other times not so much. Depends on the employee(s) and how long the pizza... by the slice has sat out. (Update: Recently a sign went up stating the original owner was back operating the store. I will haveto go in June, 2018 to update this review.) Read more

Great pizza, lots of variety. Also, prompt customer service. They explained what every pizza was. Garlic knots are great