• Closed:
    Closed (EDT)
  • Cuisine


  • Features

    Takeout , Delivery , Non-Contact Takeout

Sorry, we don’t have photos for this restaurant right now.
Sorry, we don’t have photos for this restaurant right now.
Google Reviews

Fernando John DaCunha

Nicola's is a neighborhood eatery serving up home cooked italian dishes. My wife and I visit often since we live so close - we're never disappointed. You can tell Nick pours his passion into the restaurant. Stop in or order take out, you'll definitely enjoy it.

Anne McAmbley

Sooooo yummy! Friendly, quick service, clean. And did I mention delicious?

Gem Fin

The short, thick, drunk waitress with blonde highlights needs to go. Obnoxious. She wasn't even our waitress and came over to us at the end of our meal telling my fiance she "doesn't like him" because he "gives her bad vibes". Then she accused him of waving his hand at her in a derogatory way. She was slurring her words and again... wasn't even our waitress. We did not have an interaction with her prior to this My fiance is the sweetest, quietest person, and she clearly had hin confused with someone else in her drunken stupor. The quality of the food is irrelevant to her flagrant disrespect and unprofessional behavior. We will never be back. What a disgusting establishment to allow your employees to get wasted on the job and harass your paying customers. An absolute embarrassment.

Laura Pearson

Very good food, fresh and large portions! Cozy atmosphere, too.

Jack Mercurio

Lovely! Food is tasty. Service is perfect for us. Relaxed, yet classy enough. Enjoyed Mom's 79th birthday there today.


Very friendly people at the restaurant. Wait between courses was a bit long. Due to the waitress kept getting sidetrack with idle talk with the "regulars" like 20 plus minutes or so. The food was ok too. Overall, I say a very friendly restaurant with pleasant people.

David Schoenberg

A pleasant surprise. I have passed Nicola's many times in my travels to and from Long Island, and finally decided to check it out. In a nutshell, I wish this restaurant was on Long Island because it would be my neighborhood go-to place. I have read several of the bad reviews, which mentioned plastic tablecloths, run down interior, etc. Get over yourselves. This isn't meant to be fine dining. It's a 47 year old family owned and operated restaurant. They put their heart into their food, and my wife and I found everything to be outstanding. I can't wait to go back.

James J

great service home style cooking affordable price large portions food was ok

More Google Reviews

Looking to try something new? Come to Nicola's Italian Restaurant And Catering in Cold Spring where you can try italian food like our exquisite salads. We aim to make you have the most energetic experience while at our restaurant. You can call us at (845) 809-5637 to ask any questions.

Maya Cafe - mexican (2.31 mi)
Marbled Meat Shop - american (2.42 mi)
Hometown Deli & Pizzeria - american (2.73 mi)
Elisa's Takeouts - american (2.78 mi)
I-84 Diner - american (2.82 mi)

Cities near Cold Spring
Newburgh, NY (7 mi), Wappingers Falls, NY (9 mi), Poughkeepsie, NY (15 mi)

Towns near Cold Spring
Beacon, NY (3 mi), Fishkill, NY (3 mi), Garrison, NY (7 mi), Cornwall, NY (8 mi), Highland Falls, NY (8 mi), Marlboro, NY (8 mi), New Windsor, NY (10 mi), Mahopac, NY (12 mi), Hopewell Junction, NY (12 mi), Mohegan Lake, NY (12 mi), Baldwin Place, NY (13 mi), Milton, NY (13 mi)

Want a specific cuisine? Check out our best lists for Mexican, Asian or Italian in Cold Spring. Dietary need? Let us show you all the gluten free, vegan or vegetarian options. Search Sirved for things like pizza 🍕, salad 🥗, sushi 🍣, burgers 🍔 and more. Need just a kids menu or drink menu? Sirved categorizes our menus to make exploring easier.

Frequent searches leading to this page
menu for nicola's italian restaurant and catering, 28 route, nicola's italian restaurant and catering in cold spring menu, lunch menu for nicola's italian, nicola's italian in cold spring review, nicola's italian restaurant and catering menu photos