We had a beautiful experience from three staff, the fabulous food and ambience; it all made for a wonderful evening. We started with 3 apps, the baked brie was beautiful, the gorganzola dip was delicious. Then to the pastas, steak cooked perfectly and the most delicate sauce. At the end they guft3d us a free desert for the special occasion we were celebrating
Our anniversary dinner was outstanding! We absolutely recommend this restaurant in Door County. I had made reservations a month ahead of time to make sure we could experience dining here.
The staff & service was amazing! Our waiter Romeo was a delight! However there was a 4 top that was incredibly intoxicated & disruptive for everyone else around them, I really wish staff would have addressed it. It was hard to converse & they were outright yelling at one point.
Service: 5 stars Food: 4.5 stars Atmosphere: 3.5 stars Drinks: 3.5 stars Value: 4.5 stars Service here was absolutely fantastic. Food was also excellent, but could use a better bread service. Admittedly that?s a pretty minor gripe. We tried the fish special (grouper) and the cioppino which were both good choices. Atmosphere definitely left a bit to be desired. The feel doesn?t match the quality of the food or service. Drinks were just OK but Brandy Old Fashioneds were premixed and the one off menu cocktail I ordered was completely botched, but at least we weren?t charged for it. Good prices on the wine. Come here for the food and service, and don?t expect too much from the cocktails or atmosphere. With those expectations you?ll be well served.
The service, crab cakes and seafood chowder were fantastic but our main entrees were horrible. My seafood dish was swimming in a strange tasting chili sauce was almost inedible. My daughters shrimp scampi was a pile of noodles drenched in olive oil. The seafood in both dishes were over cooked. I also called ahead to say we were there for my daughters birthday thinking she would get a dessert or something? But it wasn?t even acknowledged.
The best fried perch I've ever had! Honest to goodness. It was crunchy and perfectly cooked. The potatoes were delish. Beautiful place. FANTASTIC over the top service
If we could give 10 Stars, we would!! We are newlyweds and when my husband made reservations and let them know we just got married we were not expecting to be greeted like we were royalty. Not only did they put us in an area by ourselves the staff was phenomenal! Very attentive, very warm and gracious, and very polite. Right off the bat once we sat down served us Champagne on the house. We ordered a creme brulee for dessert to share that was also on the house. They absolutely made our first night out as husband and wife the most memorable ever; we cannot appreciate the staff more. The food was absolutely awesome and exceeded our expectations. Thank you to the chefs, maitre d, entire staff, and Romeo, our server!! 10 ?'s!! What an experience ??
We had a wonderful dinner for a family of four. The staff was friendly and service was excellent from our server Mark. Kids menu was excellent with a petite filet. They brought kids out a fresh fruit appetizer which was a beautiful touch. Food was well prepared. Drinks menu and wine list was expansive especially for Wisconsin. Will visit again.
New in town and looking for a great place to eat? Here at Alexander's of Door County we offer an extensive selection of eclectic food in Fish Creek. Ask about our scrumptious food such as salads. Take a look at our menus online or give us a call at (920) 868-3532.
Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille Fish Creek - american (1.4 mi)
Peninsula State Park Golf Course - american (1.55 mi)
Blue Horse Beach Cafe - american (1.66 mi)
BaySide Tavern - american (1.77 mi)
Fish Creek Market - american (1.77 mi)