Menu for Even Odds Pizza in Grafton, WI

Misleading Business Practices regarding their loyalty program! Recently I attempted to claim my "Free" pizza from the magnets I... have collected. I have never had an issue prior but was told that the magnets are only good for a 1 topping. I stated that wasnever the case before and if this was stated anywhere or if someone could explain to me why it had changed. I had to come in topick up my order to be able to speak to anyone outside of the person over the phone and was told "It's my business and thetoppings aren't free" I stated the coupons were misleading but was met with nothing more than a temper tantrum and no realanswer as to why it wouldn't state that anywhere or how you are supposed to even redeem them online where the person over thephone told me it supposedly mentioned the change to the policy. I have included a picture of the magnet for reference. Read more

We ordered food for our shop meeting at the new Auto Safety Center in Cedarburg. All the food was amazing, everyone agreed... ?best pizza? in the area! Kudos to Tommy and crew!! Read more

Hands down, the best pizza in Ozaukee County. Take-out and delivery only but, man, is it awesome! From the rustic thin crust to... the Detroit-style truly pan-pizza, Even Odds knows their crusts. The sauce, sweet and slightly acidic, pairs perfectly withtheir Italian sausage and pepperoni. The sides, such as spinach and feta cheesebread, are also fantastic. And how can you gowrong ordering an original Cheesecake Factory slice of dessert?! Give it a try - you won't be sorry. Read more

Friendly, fast. Ordered the Detroit pizza, tasted good and fresh but the crust was not done. Crust was soft and doughy, should... be well-done and crispy. Read more

Growing up in New York, I love my pizza. However, since moving to the area I haven't found anything that I love. Well now that's... changed. Even Odds does not make a New York style pizza. Instead they make a Detroit Style. I have never heard of Detroit Stylebut In New York we would probably call this a Sicilian style. Buts it different in a good way. The sauce and cheese are amazingand homemade. The crust is very good. The toppings are high quality. Everything was cooked extremely well and quickly. Overall Iwould highly recommend this place. Better than anything I have tried in Cedarburg or Grafton. Update after 5 year: Still great! Read more