• Open:
    11:00 AM - 08:00 PM (CDT)
  • Cuisine

    AmericanNorth American

  • Features

    Patio , Takeout , Delivery , Non-Contact Takeout

Sorry, we donโ€™t have photos for this restaurant right now.
Google Reviews


The Turkey breast was very tender. I also enjoyed their hot BBQ sauce. Rustler's has a bar! Rustler's also has a seven by amount of parking.

Penny Howell

This place is our go to place anytime we are in the area. We stopped there coming back from Hot Springs. It was Mother?s Day & was still good. Next month we will be back for some bologna! It?s the absolute best! The place is so nice & friendly staff. If anyone is ever in the area, it?s well worth the stop to eat. You won?t be disappointed.

Middle Cross Ranch

Very good food and great staff! I was a bit surprised at the cost of a brisket dinner (almost $20) but the quality and quantity are so good I'm not complaining. The staff was very friendly and accommodating. The atmosphere is great as well. Top notch place I will definitely recommend to others!

Mary Brack

Sorry I gave a previous review for the wrong restaurant. Rustler's is an excellent BBQ spot. The food was great, the staff friendly and helpful. I ordered the Mother of all Burrito's ,(MOAB). It was tasty and was so big I took part of it home for dinner. The Big Jake was ordered by two member's of my party and the sandwich was loaded with meat. I would highly recommend this place to everyone. Visit this place when you get near Henrietta, OK. You will not regret it.

John Brack

The food was tasty and the staff was excellent. I had been waiting for this restaurant to open for month's. I called today and was advised they opened on Monday. The young lady I spoke to said for the opening first week they were offering 15% off the bill. I forgot to check and later learned we did not get the discount. The menu is limited and this is the first seafood restaurant I've been to that does not have Gumbo and Etouffe. I hope they add these to the menu. It would also be nice to get some type of bread with the pasta. You get pasta and nothing else. Will give them another try since the food was good.

Brandon Cutts

Great atmosphere here. Was going to try the spicy Ruben just because I like Ruben?s. The girl at the counter wasn?t real convincing to get it. I told her I wanted to try lots of stuff then. Guy behind me told me to get the 5 meat platter. Ended up going with his recommendation. But I added some chop and a couple of ribs. Cost me $40.00 for what?s pictured. At first I felt like that was way too much money for what I was getting. But when it came out, I could have easily shared that with someone and we would have both been full. The bbq is good. It?s not great, but it was good. They have a pretty neat sauce dispenser. It?s like milking a cow! Lolol. Wish I would have gotten pics of that. Super friendly place. I was just passing through and seen that it had 4.7 stars. I was hoping for some better smoke flavor, but some don?t like too much smoke. I like to taste the flavor of the wood used. I would recommend going there. Seemed like really nice people behind the counter and place was very clean. Clean restrooms as well. I left full and left with a pretty big To go box.

Jerry Teltow

Didn't know what to expect. Real clean inside. Seated a large group of us (25) and brought our food. BBQ was very good. Brisket, Ribs and Sausage was very good. Highly recommend.

Shelly Hubbard

We have been trying to get here for more than a year. The BBQ was worth the wait! Ribs were fall off the bone tasty, pulled pork and slices brisket were really great! Sides were amazing! Service was really good (they checked on us 4 times). Absolutely amazing! We'll be back very soon!!!

More Google Reviews

Our customers at Rustler's BBQ have come to expect some of the best american food in Henryetta. Drop on by or give us a call at (918) 650-9800 to make a reservation. Find our salads and you'll be delighted that you did. We're just down the street.

Tapatio Mexican Restaurant - mexican (1.13 mi)
Kirby's Cafe - american (12.38 mi)
Ali's Place II - american (18.46 mi)
John's Bar-B-Q - american (18.62 mi)
Hen House Venue - american (18.98 mi)

Towns near Henryetta
Okmulgee, OK (12 mi), Okemah, OK (19 mi), Eufaula, OK (23 mi), Checotah, OK (25 mi)

Sirved has 17 restaurant menus for Henryetta, Oklahoma. Want a specific cuisine? Check out our best lists for Mexican, Asian or Italian in Henryetta. Dietary need? Let us show you all the vegetarian, gluten free or vegan options. Search Sirved for things like soup 🥣, burgers 🍔, pizza 🍕, tacos 🌮 and more. Need just a kids menu or drink menu? Sirved categorizes our menus to make exploring easier.

Frequent searches leading to this page
131 paul carr dr, rustler's bbq menu, rustler's bbq in henryetta review, rustler's bbq menu photos, rustler's bbq lunch menu, rustler's bbq in henryetta