Menu for Sheldons Street Pizza in Lake Orion, MI

I like this pizza, they are fast and local which is great. I'm not giving 5 stars because they did not spread the pepperoni... slices evenly over the pizza, they were just stacked in the same spot in some pieces, there were other pizza pieces with nopepperoni at all. Read more

Sheldon's been making the best pizza for as long as I've been in Michigan. The freshest salads, toppings, and dough. Both... Detroit style and hand tossed are fantastic. The best pizza in the area hands down. -John 101 Read more

Best pizza around, and Sheldon and his staff are super friendly and attentive to detail. They also have excellent chicken... wings, unlike most pizza places that just do them as an after thought. Highly recommend Sheldons Street Pizza! Read more

The owner seems to be a decent guy and offered me fair resolution for my poor experience of ordering 2 slices at lunch and being... charged for the "lunch special". The 16.9 oz beverage was not good, but I haven't had a Sprite in years, so maybe it was achange in Coke's recipe, but nasty nonetheless. The girl at the register asked if I wanted the special and so I asked what itwas. She said, "2 slices and a beverage from their cooler". I had a beverage that I had just bought, so I said no and ordered 2slices. She charged me for the special anyway. ???? The 2 slices of pizza weren't in my opinion 'up to the value' of paying $7and change for, and the beverage was dumped out as soon as I got home, but my experience with Sheldon on the phone was a verypositive one. Though I probably won't retrieve a refund because Sheldon seemed like a fair businessman. So, my first somewhat'off colored' review of any pizza place was drastically improved because of Sheldon's "will to do good" businesspractices. Good luck Sheldon! If you were to be open for suggestions I would likely advise you to possibly tighten up yourstaff or maybe lower the prices of your slices, bud. Thank you for your time and service to do the best you can for yourcommunity. Sincerely, John Read more

My first time trying Sheldon?s street pizza & let me tell you it was DELICIOUS! I ordered the Hawaiian pizza with green olives &... feta and the cheese bread with garlic cream cheese and I highly recommend both!! I didn?t expect the delivery to be so fast so Ijumped in the shower and the delivery guy had to wait for me outside, he was so polite and understanding when I finally was ableto answer my phone. I will definitely be ordering again and leaving more than a 20% tip from now on. Thank you for the deliciousfood and outstanding customer service! Read more