Absolutely excellent. Great food and friendly staff!
Great personal environment. Staff were excellent and friendly in service. We went on a Thursday night which was not busy at all. We ordered battered mushrooms and mozzarella sticks to start off. Then ordered the large Meatlover's (really excellent and very real tasting cheese), and the large Papa Carlo special (excellent thin green pepper slices). We finished off the meal with a turtle cheesecake (quite good). Overall, a great dining experience and would dine in again. Cheers!
This place has a cute atmosphere, friendly staff! Pasta is my go-to, pizza is next on the list though I?ve heard great things!
We ordered 2 medium choose your own topping pizzas and a side order of calamari. My only real complaint is that it was pretty expensive! However everything was delicious! The toppings on the pizza aren?t heavy they are just adequate but flavourful. I like cheese on my pizza to be a slight bit crispy and this was definitely the case. Don?t hesitate to order the white cream sauce on your pizza because it was also very full of flavour (some places when I?ve ordered a cream or white sauce they are totally bland but you won?t find that here). The dough has a lovely texture and great taste and crunch. The lightly battered calamari was a little greasy but tasted fantastic especially the dipping sauce it came with. We will definitely be back!
Had a great dinner served by a lovely young women who I believe her name was Megan. Food was great but she made the dinner ten times better with her service!
Amazing pizza. Perfect crust. Delicious sauce. Very generous toppings. Calamari was also perfect. Prices are very reasonable. Family owned. Definitely going back, a nice treat for us. Much better than your average city place and equally as good as the overpriced city places!
Very good pizza. I think it is the best pizza in the Selkirk area. Also a great place to dine in....but quite busy.
Great pizza and great service! We have eaten here a number of times now and not a miss. Pizza is in the top 5 that I have had in the world. Bold statement but really is one of my favourites. Check it out, very confident you will not be disappointed
Foodies ahoy! At Papa Carlo Pizzeria & Gelati we provide an amazing culinary experience in Lockport. Our experienced chefs have worked hard to bring you food such as sandwiches to excite your palate. Call us at (204) 757-4330 to make a reservation for the best italian food in town.
Gaffer's Restaurant & Lounge - canadian, american (1.47 km)
Half Moon Drive In - canadian (1.71 km)
Golf & Country Club - american (7.58 km)
Frank's Pizza - italian, american (7.73 km)
Selkirk Golf & Country Club - american (7.8 km)