Menu for The Oyster Society in Marco Island, FL

  • Closed:
    4:30 PM - 10:30 PM
  • Contact:
  • Cuisines:

    American North American

    American North American

  • Features:


  • Dietary:


  • Known for:

    Romantic, Vegetarian options, Upscale, Wine, Kids menu, Wi-Fi, Casual, Live music, Beer, Cocktails, Coffee, Great dessert, Happy hour drinks, Happy hour food, Healthy options, Small plates, Cozy, Bar onsite, Good for groups, Solo dining, Curbside pickup, Fast service, High chairs, Delivery, Takeaway, Restroom, Dinner, Seating, Outdoor seating, Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Wheelchair accessible restroom, Wheelchair accessible seating, Credit Card Payments, Debit cards, Popular with Tourists, Dinner reservations recommended, Alcohol, Dessert, Dine-in, Dinner, Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits, Mask required, Hard liquor, Accepts reservations,
    Read more

The Oyster Society in Marco Island, FL, is a American restaurant with an overall average rating of 4.7 stars. Check out what other diners have said about The Oyster Society. Today, The Oyster Society is open from 4:30 PM to 10:30 PM. Worried you’ll miss out? Reserve your table by calling ahead on (239) 394-3474.

Enjoy your favorite dish at home by ordering from The Oyster Society through OpenTable.

There’s something for everyone at The Oyster Society, including vegetarian dietary options.

Other attributes on top of the menu include: kids menu.

For a similar meal experience, check out Dolce Mare and Da Vinci Ristorante Italiano as an alternative.

Have you eaten here before? Leave a review!

Robert Arsenault 1 year ago

Our second time here, last night was for a full dinner and many cocktails. Today, we came back for happy hour and was not... disappointed, we had six different happy hour choices, and all were spectacular. Also. We had mixed drinks and old Fashioneds,they were made great and the service was spectacular. Our waitress knocked it out of the park. This restaurant is highlyrecommended. Read more

Joe Pellegrini 1 year ago

We had an amazing dinner at Oyster society. We had made a reservation for 7:30 but went around 7:00 to have a drink at the... bar. Sean was our bartender. He made the most beautiful Mai Tai that I've ever seen! We enjoyed sitting at the bar so decidedto order dinner there and not move to a table. Everything we ordered from the Oyster trio and grilled octopus to the potatocrusted grouper and scampi was cooked and presented perfectly! These people really know how to do things right! Read more

Jennifer Peluso 1 year ago

We had made reservations for my birthday, in the open tables notes I made them aware we needed a high chair and food allergies.... I also requested a specific booth. They sat us at the booth next to the one I wanted to sit in, our server was too busy tohandle another table. When we first sat I noticed my plate was had food on it so I asked someone if they could bring me a newone. He didn’t apologize, just snagged it out of my hand and never returned with a new one. Our server dropped bread and ranaway. We sat waiting, figuring out what we were having and wished we had a server to answer our questions about the menu or evenjust tell us their specials for the night. When she quickly came back she took a drink order and tried to run but I managed tolet here know we wanted a salad to start. When ishe came back with our drinks my husband asked what the special was. She pointedher finger up at him and said once second, dropped the drinks and ran away again. We had yet to even be properly greeted, shenever told us her name and I couldn’t believe she pointed her finger at my husband. I was beyond annoyed. I had to go saysomething for her to even remember to return to us. She quietly told us about specials and we told her we were ready. After shetook our orders she left and my husband said it seemed like she had an attitude. Thankfully the food was beyond amazing. But atthe end a family member asked for a birthday dessert without chocolate and it was in the notes and they brought me out achocolate moose dessert. ??????????? At that point the server literally said she couldn’t catch a break from our table. Sheended up bringing another dessert plus another table bought us a dessert. My family and I couldn’t help but laugh. For thelocation and the prices I would expect better customer service if I were to return. But the food will definitely have me givingthem a second chance. Plus our bartender prior to sitting was really polite and friendly. Too bad he couldn’t hav Read more

Bang ! 1 year ago

We had a great dinner here on our trip at Marco Island. Location is very close to our timeshare at Marriott Crystal Shore so... after checking the review of some places nearby, we decided to go to The Oyster Society, and we are soooo glad to make the rightexecutive-decision. The restaurant decor and setup like Italian style looks very upscale and warm, friendly welcome. We madereservation online and arrived on time, got table right away and our serve Greta was quickly came greeted us. She mentioned somespecial today's dishes so we ordered oyster, hotpot and salad for appetizer, then main course are grouper, 16oz NY steak, andsushi roll. Oysters were very fresh and flavorful, Steak was big and done perfect. Grouper was good (my husband said a bit fishyto him) Sushi roll was very good (better than Japanese restaurant we went in Orlando). Everything was so yummy and enough foodsfor our family of 4 with 13yo and 3yo kids, and we actually got full, got leftover for midnight snack and our bill includedglass of wine ($208) was same with other places we tried but never got full. Great service. Great foods. Great location. Greatdining experience to add on our trip. We all love it. Thank you. We def. will be back! Read more

Brady Schmitz 1 year ago

I stopped in for happy hour on a Wednesday at about 5:15. I had a great crowd a great buzz and good energy. I sat at the bar... outside and had phenomenal service. I ordered the blood orange margarita the octopus and spicy tuna bites. All of them were veryvery good and I loved the blood orange margarita! Such a good vibe and energy this is a must stop if you're in Marco. Read more

Q & A

Activity Feed


When is The Oyster Society open?

The Oyster Society is open on the following days:
Monday: 04:30 PM - 10:00 PM
Tuesday: 04:30 PM - 10:00 PM
Wednesday: 04:30 PM - 10:00 PM
Thursday: 04:30 PM - 10:00 PM
Friday: 04:30 PM - 10:30 PM
Saturday: 04:30 PM - 10:30 PM
Sunday: 04:30 PM - 10:00 PM

What forms of payment are accepted at The Oyster Society?

They accept Credit and Debit at The Oyster Society.

Does The Oyster Society offer delivery?

Yes, The Oyster Society offers delivery.

Does The Oyster Society offer reservations?

Yes, The Oyster Society accepts reservations.

Does The Oyster Society offer desserts?

Yes, The Oyster Society has dessert, view their dessert menu on Sirved.