• Open:
    11:00 AM - 08:00 PM (MDT)
  • Cuisine

    AmericanNorth American

  • Features

    Patio , Takeout , Delivery

  • Dietary


Sorry, we don’t have photos for this restaurant right now.
Sorry, we don’t have photos for this restaurant right now.
Google Reviews

Patty Dailey

Shared an amazing pepperoni and olive calzone. I always use Ranch for dipping and their ranch is homemade. The calzone was generous, we even had a piece leftover. Yummm.

Matt Cox

Great Pizza. We were starving after a long day and we were looking forward to pizza. We ordered a Chicken bacon ranch and an Italian pizza. The crust is great. The thickness is perfect, not too thick and not too thin. The chicken basic ranch was really good with strips of bacon and not just bacon bits. The Italian had a great proportion of Italian sausage and veggies. What a great meal in a beautiful town. Highly recommend you give it a try out you are in Marysvale.

Dawn S

While out on a scenic drive around dinner time, we found this lovely little hole in the wall to satisfy our hunger. We got a large three topping and it was amazeballs. The atmosphere was great. They were busy but they took great care of everyone. We will be back!

Josh 4 Four 5 & a Half

Absolutely amazing authentic delicious pizza and bread sticks. Love this place !!

Michael Burnham

Pure serendipity! I had read reviews that this place was good but it was even better than the reviews said. I would've been happy with just good pizza and frankly that's what I expected from a small town pizzeria, but it was gourmet. The pizza was top notch and the cheesey bread sticks were the best I've ever had, no joke. The service was excellent, the restaurant clean, and the Italian cheesecake for dessert was delicious. I'll be making excuses to drive down to central Utah just to eat here. It's now in my top pizza joints in Utah along with Jack's in Logan and the Pie downtown.

Chadwick Priest

This pizza was straight fire! So good. Loved the flavor and they did the crust how I like it. This place is an example of why independent pizzerias are the best. I was kinda salty about driving 40 min round trip until I had that first bite. Just wonderful. Glad my airbnb host had recommended it. Staff was very chill and professional.

Katie Garrett

Ok, if you?re looking for authentic NYC pizza in the middle of nowhere, this is the place!! I absolutely loved my experience here because the service was fast and perfectly done and the food was spectacular! I went here with a group of 7 and we got the family deal that includes a 20 inch pizza, wings, 4 sodas, and cheese bread for $38.99. We also ordered an extra 20 inch pizza and we finished everything! The thin crust pizza with delectable toppings were such a treat out in Marysvale. Definitely will be coming here next time I pass through that area!

Joslin Hebertson

Food is amazing!! Best cheese bread and marinara sauce. Supreme Pizza was off the hook! Not too think of crust, tons of yummy Mozzarella loaded with toppings. Their crust and sauces are made fresh daily! Yum! It shows! Service is as good as their food!!! Definitely will come here again!

More Google Reviews

If it's great american food that you're after try Tomatoes Pizza Pie in Marysvale. Discover some of the most interesting menus in town. Try our specials such at wings and you'll be back for more. Call us at (435) 326-4444 and we'll save the best table in town.

Paradox Grille - american (176.28 mi)
Paradox Grille - american (176.31 mi)
Stateline Bar & Grill - american (178.75 mi)
Wienerschnitzel - american (193.95 mi)
Starvin Arvin's - american (194.23 mi)

Towns near Marysvale
Beaver, UT (12 mi), Richfield, UT (22 mi)

Want a specific cuisine? Check out our best lists for Asian, Mexican or Italian in Marysvale. Dietary need? Let us show you all the vegetarian, vegan or gluten free options. Search Sirved for things like sushi 🍣, burgers 🍔, pizza 🍕, wings and more. Need just a kids menu or drink menu? Sirved categorizes our menus to make exploring easier.

Frequent searches leading to this page
tomatoes pizza pie in marysvale, tomatoes pizza pie lunch menu, tomatoes pizza menu, tomatoes pizza in marysvale reviews, tomatoes pizza menu photos, 10 e