• Closed:
    12:00 PM - 10:00 PM (EDT)
  • Cuisine

    AmericanNorth American

  • Features

    Takeout , Delivery

Sorry, we don’t have photos for this restaurant right now.
Sorry, we don’t have photos for this restaurant right now.
Google Reviews

Chuck Roemer

We had a great time , and got plenty of ice cream for the money


Rarely do I look at a serving size and think it is enough. So I got three scoops here. My first thought was wow thats too much!!! Delicious!


Missing a star for no cherries. No cherries!? What's up with that? As far as everything else, the staff was super friendly and fast. The line was to the road and the wait was less then 20 minutes. It was very reasonable. The lady at the register was super nice. Banana split was amazing. Try a banana split with brownie ice cream and carmel.

Theresa Schmitz

Large portions. 2 scoop hard ice cream too much to finish, awesome!!! Medium soft serve is a tower of luscious delight! Great value, pleasant employees! Wonderful experience! Highly recommended x6!

Kevin Gratzer

Great selection and Wow with the portions. Excellent! Will need to go back again soon.

Christopher Corporandy

Amazing ice cream. Slow service but that?s ok. Part of the community, good summer tradition. Get the ice cream Flight so you can have 4 flavors! HUGE servings on all sizes.

Nick Meyer

Delicious ice cream. Beware the sizes... they're humongous. A large could feed a family of four for a week. They even have some vegan flavors

Steve Churchill

On our tour of ice cream places in Western PA, Eastern OH and SW NY, we happen to stumble upon Boxcar Barney's. Really nice location, you can sit in the Adirondack chairs or lounge at the picnic tables to enjoy the view (remotely) of the lake. Very pretty setting and perfect for a sunny summer day and ice cream. We always comment on how some places have "grainy" soft serve or varying degrees of creamy. Here, we totally enjoyed the creaminess of the soft serve. A bit of a surprise for two small cones coming in at ten bucks but then again, the portions were generous and the location made up for the rest. Cones without a paper sleeve, which was odd, seeing we live in the age of Covid. Regardless, nice place, nice staff and a good old fashioned treat on a day made for it. Oh ... and the only place we have seen so far with PASTEL sprinkles. Not a huge thing but enough to set it apart from all the other standard color sprinkles. FUN!

More Google Reviews

Boxcar Barney's - Seasonal Hours May - Labor Day in Mayville is the place to go for american food in the region.Find our many daily specials and featured menu items such as sandwiches and you'll be back for more. Give us a call at (716) 584-3066 and we'll greet you at the door!

Docks - american (0.3 mi)
Webb's Captain's Table Restaurant - american (0.33 mi)
Watermark Restaurant - american (0.39 mi)
Andriaccio's Restaurant - italian (2.49 mi)
2 Ames - american (2.72 mi)

Cities near Mayville
Jamestown, NY (3 mi)

Towns near Mayville
Bemus Point, NY (6 mi), Westfield, NY (7 mi), Lakewood, NY (14 mi), North East, PA (14 mi), Fredonia, NY (16 mi), Dunkirk, NY (17 mi), Corry, PA (22 mi)

Want a specific cuisine? Check out our best lists for Mexican, Asian or Italian in Mayville. Dietary need? Let us show you all the gluten free, vegetarian or vegan options. Search Sirved for things like tacos 🌮, pasta , salad 🥗, burgers 🍔 and more. Need just a kids menu or drink menu? Sirved categorizes our menus to make exploring easier.

Frequent searches leading to this page
boxcar barney's in mayville, boxcar barney's food photos, boxcar barney's in mayville, boxcar barney's menu, lunch menu for boxcar barney's, boxcar barney's in mayville reviews