Sorry, we don’t have photos for this restaurant right now.
Google Reviews

Brittany Pisani

We had our son?s 2nd bday party catered from here this weekend. The people we spoke to were extremely nice and accommodating. I actually said to my husband after getting off the phone that that was one of the most pleasant conversations I?ve ever had with a restaurant in general. They were extremely helpful with my parents when picking up the food also and their catering packages are amazing. I can?t tell you how many people asked me where the food was from while at the party and after. Everyone is raving about how great the food was and are asking me for the info for their own parties. We will only ever order here for parties from now on, thank you!!

Rhonda Finder

Truly a hidden gem! This restaurant is an absolute ? must go to? if you want a restaurant that is clean, has very friendly staff, ( especially one of the sons, John Michael)comfortable tables, and of course, PHENOMENAL HOME STYLE Italian food.. There is most definitely a reason my husband and I saw people in parties of 4 or more continuously coming in here! Btw, the cannoli?s? ? off the hook? delicious! ? Friendly advice? COME ONE, COME ALL! Bravo

Vanessa Saunders

Amazing pizza, amazing service, great prices, convenient location! And they have zeppolis which are such a great treat! We've had their regular pie and pan pizza. Both are *chef's kiss*. My husband has had the caprese salad and loves it! 100% recommend

Ania azuka

A colleague of mine said this pizzeria is better than Cafe Gia, but for me $5 is highly inflated** for ?1-slice of eggplant parm? (way too quite pricey!!!)?I?m use to $3.75 for specialty slices. Also, the thickness of the slice isn?t my thing. I prefer thin crust, voile?lower carbs. One thing I must say is your pizza is surely less oily than Cafe Gia but better quality not so sure. Yeah no I?m still leaning towards gia ??

Alex Borg

I've been to over two dozen pizzerias around central/eastern Long Island and this is THE BEST spot around. THEY KNOW PIZZA. Always fast, even when crowded

Nysports Mcp

Always a good experience. Great staff always friendly and attentive. The food is flexible and all spectacular. They are known for their great individual pizzas, rightfully so. They have a great pizza selection. The margherita is my fave. That being said, this is far from simply just a pizza joint. Their pasta and protein dishes are all tasty with generous size portions. Good Penne alla vodka sauce.

Anthony Sileo

I?m sad to give this family 1 star, but not for nothing. We?ve been ordering pizza there since 1997, and we?ve had nothing but great service. My parents got diagnosed with covid and to surprise them I ordered them a margarita pizza, when I got home my parents were thankful but the pizza wasn?t crispy, and the cheese was soggy. Very nicely my mother called and one of the sons called her a liar, because she explained that I was picking up the pizza and noticed that the son took it out of the regular oven and not the brick oven, then my father and I drove down there, and I was being yelled at by one of the sons, he was telling me I?ll get the security cameras out and show you I took the pizza out of the brick oven. Either way I?m disappointed with the service abs I?ll never go again they should be ashamed of themselves.

Steven Tringali

Another awesome dinner at La Margherita! Tonight we started with a half bottle of Caberne Savignone.....spelled correctly???? We ordered a brick oven Margherita pizza to start. It was so delicious and crisp. For dinner, I had my usual, veal Parmigiano which was outstanding and plentiful. And leftovers too! My wife ordered the eggplant rollatini which she enjoyed too. The dishes were hot and cheesy! John Michael, our waiter was great, very personable and full of energy, we had a great time tonight! The food is excellent, enjoy!

More Google Reviews

Looking for nutritious and delicious meals? La Margherita Pizzeria is just a call away at (631) 924-0048 when you want to find out what's cooking. Find our italian food such as pasta. For many years lots of folks have considered us the best place to eat in Medford.

Cafe Gia - italian (0.33 mi)
Top of the Bay - american (0.57 mi)
Old Dock Grill - american (0.6 mi)
Billie Jeans Grill Food Truck - american (1.65 mi)
Medford Pastaria - american (1.74 mi)

Cities near Medford
Patchogue, NY (3 mi), Smithtown, NY (12 mi), Bay Shore, NY (16 mi)

Towns near Medford
Yaphank, NY (1 mi), Bellport, NY (2 mi), Brookhaven, NY (3 mi), East Patchogue, NY (3 mi), Holtsville, NY (4 mi), Coram, NY (4 mi), Shirley, NY (5 mi), Farmingville, NY (5 mi), Middle Island, NY (5 mi), Mastic, NY (6 mi), Blue Point, NY (6 mi), Selden, NY (6 mi)

Sirved has 29 restaurant menus for Medford, New York. Want a specific cuisine? Check out our best lists for Italian, Asian or Mexican in Medford. Dietary need? Let us show you all the vegetarian, vegan or gluten free options. Search Sirved for things like sushi 🍣, tacos 🌮, burgers 🍔, salad 🥗 and more. Need just a kids menu or drink menu? Sirved categorizes our menus to make exploring easier.

Frequent searches leading to this page
2 pulaski rd, la margherita pizzeria in medford menu, lunch menu for la margherita, menu for la margherita pizzeria, la margherita pizzeria food photos, la margherita pizzeria in medford reviews