Menu for Arni's Monticello in Monticello, IN

  • Open:
    11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
  • Contact:
  • Cuisines:

    American North American

    American North American

  • Features:

    Takeout , Delivery

  • Known for:

    Good for kids, Casual, Cozy, Kids menu, Quick bite, Coffee, Good for groups, Solo dining, Family-friendly, Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits, LGBTQ+ friendly, Mask required, Accepts reservations, Catering, Curbside pickup, Fast service, High chairs, Restroom, Seating, Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Wheelchair accessible restroom, Wheelchair accessible seating, Credit Card Payments, Debit cards, College students, Popular with Tourists, Dessert, Dine-in, Dinner, Popular Dinner, Lunch, Popular Lunch,
    Read more

Arni's Monticello in Monticello, IN, is a well-established American restaurant that boasts an average rating of 4 stars. Learn more about other diner's experiences at Arni's Monticello. Today, Arni's Monticello is open from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM. Don’t risk not having a table. Call ahead and reserve your table by calling (574) 583-2764.

For a similar meal experience, check out An Extra Scoop and Abe's Pizza as an alternative.

Have you dined here before? Leave a review!

Laud Williams 1 year ago

The pizza was amazing. It tasted like it sad made fresh. The cajun spice on it was definitely a plus. It's a must visit when in... town. Read more

Judith Kline 1 year ago

Got an Arni's Jr. Salad tonight with ranch dressing and it was loaded with toppings and so good. It's the Best!!!

Asjah Fedrick 1 year ago

I ordered a bacon cheeseburger and paid for one. I opened my sandwich in my car and realized immediately I didn?t see any bacon.... I walk back in for them to make it right and the cook says it?s under the burger. You know what happened when I got back to myjob and bit into the burger; no bacon. I?m really annoyed and upset because you lied saying that there was bacon and therewasn?t. I wasn?t even mad at first because I know things happen but for you to lie to my face as if I were the problem. That isjust wrong on so many levels and unprofessional especially when I paid for bacon. On top of that the meat tasted old and notfresh?.Now I have to work the rest of my shift hungry because my coworker left for the evening. Thanks. Read more

Chris Hawkins 1 year ago

Tots were good. Stromboli was good too but the toppings go on the sandwich not the plate. Might try it out again, probably not.

Drensik Scowden 1 year ago

So right off the bat, I was second guessing this restaurant because the outside of the building is falling apart. Rotten wood... everywhere. The building looks deserted, the parking lot has no lines, we weren't really sure where to park. Went inside andthe layout is very strange. There were laminated signs saying pickup or dine in, otherwise I would have thought it was pickuponly because there's no obvious place to sit when you first go in. This isn't a problem in itself, but it became an issuebecause they make you order before you sit down. I came with a group and we hadn't decided what to eat... and there were novisible menus posted. So we had to awkwardly stand there and guess at things that might be on the menu. Once we decided, theguy at the register wrote our order down. He was very rude and kept mumbling, we couldn't understand what he was saying when heanswered our questions... and the whole time we were ordering there was a woman standing next to him, arms crossed in front ofher, glaring at us. Way to make us feel welcome? We made our way down the hallway to the seating area and 75% of the tableswere filthy, even though they were not anywhere close to being busy. You have to carry your own drinks to your table, which isfine. They all tasted like dirty water, no flavor to them. We did not have to wait long, the pizza was good, and the guy whobrought the pizza out was nice. We asked a woman for two boxes and she never came back. So we went up front to ask again andshe practically threw a fit about it, then gave one box so we had to ask again. In summary, the pizza is good but the peopleare rude and the place is absolutely disgusting. I won't be back, it's not worth it. Read more

Q & A

Activity Feed


When is Arni's Rensselaer open?

Arni's Rensselaer is open on the following days:

Monday: 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Tuesday: 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Wednesday: 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Thursday: 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Friday: 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Saturday: 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Sunday: 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

What forms of payment are accepted at Arni's Rensselaer?

They accept Credit and Debit at Arni's Rensselaer.

Does Arni's Rensselaer offer delivery?

Yes, Arni's Rensselaer offers delivery.