Menu for Brooklyn and The Butcher in New Albany, IN

  • Open:
    5:00 PM - 9:00 PM
  • Contact:
  • Cuisines:

    American North American

    American North American

  • Features:


  • Dietary:


  • Known for:

    Beer, Cocktails, Coffee, Great coffee, Great dessert, Healthy options, Late-night food, Cozy, Small plates, Historic, Vegetarian options, Romantic, Wine, Upscale, Wi-Fi, Comfort food, Dinner reservations recommended, Alcohol, Brunch, Dessert, Dine-in, Dinner, Transgender safespace, Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits, Hard liquor, Accepts reservations, Lunch, Good for groups, Bar onsite, Solo dining, Curbside pickup, Family-friendly, High chairs, LGBTQ+ friendly, Restroom, Seating, Delivery, Outdoor seating, Takeaway, Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Wheelchair-accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible restroom, Wheelchair accessible seating, Dinner, Identifies as women-owned, Credit Card Payments, Debit cards, Popular with Tourists,
    Read more

Brooklyn and The Butcher in New Albany, IN, is a popular American restaurant that has earned an average rating of 4.4 stars. Learn more by reading what others have to say about Brooklyn and The Butcher. Don’t miss out! Today, Brooklyn and The Butcher will open from 10:00 AM to 9:00 PM. Whether you’re a small party of two or celebrating with a group, call ahead and reserve your table at (812) 590-2646.

Stay home and order out from Brooklyn and The Butcher through OpenTable.

Brooklyn and The Butcher includes vegetarian dietary options.

Other attributes include: beer.

Love the menu, but want to try somewhere new? Try Lady Tron's and Toast On Market.

Have you dined here before? Leave a review!

Katie Stewart 1 year ago

My first time in. My Mom and I were celebrating my brother’s 21st birthday. Let me add I live with a chef and manage a... restaurant. I really didn’t have super high expectations, but let me tell you, this place knocked it out of the park! Ourserver, Amanda was super knowledgeable and went out of her way to make our dining experience memorable. The chef board wasincredible! My drink, stir crazy, was smoked at the table! It smelled like a camp fire and was quite possibly the best drinkI’ve ever had! My wedge salad was also incredible! Every single thing: the food, drinks, and service were incredible andexceeded my expectations. It was a memorable outing! Thank you to Amanda and staff for your excellent teamwork! Read more

Erin Schwab 1 year ago

The dining room and bar area are nice and service was decent. Ordered the mussels appetizer and it was so spicy it masked the... actual flavor of the mussels and my husband and I like and can handle spicy heat just fine. It stated Coconut Curry in sauce onmenu so we expected a little heat, however it was too spicy for the delicacy of mussels. I ordered the crab tagliatelle whichwas fine, and my husband ordered the salmon, which again was way too spicy for seafood. When a sauce is so spicy it over powersthe actual flavor of the protein it isn’t worth it. The server also stated they prepare salmon to a temp of medium yet thesalmon was over cooked and a little tough due to the over cooking. Overall the dinner was not worth the price as we could havegotten similar quality dishes at a less expensive establishment. Will most likely not go back. Read more

Tanya Parke 1 year ago

Food is a bit pricey but you know that going in. I chose the sirloin, med rare and it was cooked perfectly and had a wonderful... taste/texture. Sides for most of the steaks are separate but are enough to share between a couple of people. We werecelebrating a birthday and they allowed us to bring in a cake with us. Allow time to secure parking in downtown New Albany.You're competing with several restaurants and construction. While I did see people bring in very young children, this reallyisn't the best place for them. Read more

Billy meredith 1 year ago

Had brunch last Sunday. Service and food pretty good. Pretty quiet and nice. I believe it’s a old hotel. Btw those fries are... amazing! Read more

Megan Paz 1 year ago

We will definitely be returning! We went to Brooklyn and the Butcher for my husband's b-day & they had some of the electable... items to try. My husband and I shared their special porterhouse and the octopus was cooked perfectly. Paired with a French wineand I'm hooked! Read more

Q & A

Activity Feed


When is Brooklyn and The Butcher open?

Brooklyn and The Butcher is open on the following days:
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 05:00 PM - 09:00 PM
Wednesday: 05:00 PM - 09:00 PM
Thursday: 05:00 PM - 09:00 PM
Friday: 05:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Saturday: 05:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Sunday: 10:00 AM - 02:00 PM 05:00 PM - 09:00 PM

What forms of payment are accepted at Brooklyn and The Butcher?

They accept Credit and Debit at Brooklyn and The Butcher.

Does Brooklyn and The Butcher offer delivery?

Yes, Brooklyn and The Butcher offers delivery.

Does Brooklyn and The Butcher offer reservations?

Yes, Brooklyn and The Butcher accepts reservations.