• Open:
    11:30 AM - 10:00 PM (EDT)
  • Cuisine

    AmericanNorth American

  • Features

    Patio , Takeout , Delivery , Non-Contact Takeout

  • Dietary

    Gluten Free

Google Reviews

John Poels

Lunch was served on a metal tray with nothing to grace it but the sandwich itself and a reversed cone of fries. The fries were difficult to access after the top section was consumed so I extracted the inside wrapper and placed it on the barren tray. The sandwich itself had decent flavor but I felt the portion was small for the price. I asked our waiter to please watch my water level as I have a tendency to drink a lot of liquid with my food. Didn't happen. My daughter wound up giving me her glass of water. Three lunches with two waters, a drink and three sandwiches plus tip came to around $75. As we all know, presentation, flavor and portion make for a decent meal and my lunch lacked two of those. Add in the waitstaff and you can understand why the place was almost empty.

Kisha MP

Wow! Wish I could say something nice, but I can't! Selections sounded good but the order was subpar. First of all, part of good customer service is following customers' request....no pickles or tomatoes means just that! Then add the mayo and ketchup as requested. Also prices are outrageous, $10 for a slice of cake just because it's gluten free? C'mon!!

Tammie King

We enjoyed our dinner as we always do. Iy wasn't too crowded inside and a look around the dining room saw families enjoying their night. The food was delicious. Whether you go for chicken picatta or eggplant parm, you won't be disappointed. The only thing I would do different next time is ask for more sauce with the fried ravioli appetizer.

Ben D

Good clam chowder. But I was a bit surprised by the bowl of "Canola oil" served with the bread. I puked a little when I heard what I just ate.

Sydney Lyvers

Service was subpar. Our waitress only had 4 tables. Tables that arrived after us with the same amount of people were already getting food before us. My beer had a bug in it no one addressed it until my boyfriend finally took it to the bar himself. Our waitress kept bringing us the wrong drinks or not bringing items we asked for. We had to wait 20 minutes for refills on our drinks. The food was okay but almost cold by the time it arrived at our table. She checked on the other tables more than she check on us. Not worth the money spent here. The place was very slow too. There was maybe 10 tables taken the whole time we were there mad no one at the bar.

Beatrice Fernando

Went here for lunch and it reminded me why I never come here. I ordered chicken wrap and pizza it was the worst I ever had. Never go back.

Andrea Li

Great gluten free menu. They offer gluten free rolls and and lots of appetizers and main courses. The not your average Joe?s Peabody location is moderately and clean! Lot?s of parking available and you can enter trough the Mall. My children love the bread and oil.

Lance Woolfolk

Beautiful place great atmosphere, and very clean. Great waitress, and the food was delicious. The price was a little higher then I expected for the Lobster Roll, but it was delicious.

More Google Reviews

Peabody has lots of great places to eat, but none better than Not Your Average Joe's. Call (978) 839-5637 to make reservations and ask about our tasty desserts too.

Amigo's Mexican Kitchen & Tequila Bar - mexican (0.08 mi)
Pellana - american (0.46 mi)
Endicott Grille - american (0.5 mi)
Kelly's Roast Beef - american (0.57 mi)
Century House Restaurant - american (0.63 mi)

Cities near Peabody
Salem, MA (3 mi), Lynn, MA (3 mi), Danvers, MA (4 mi), Beverly, MA (4 mi), Saugus, MA (5 mi), Revere, MA (8 mi), Malden, MA (8 mi), Woburn, MA (10 mi), Everett, MA (10 mi)

Towns near Peabody
Lynnfield, MA (4 mi), Swampscott, MA (5 mi), Middleton, MA (5 mi), Marblehead, MA (5 mi), Wakefield, MA (7 mi), Reading, MA (8 mi), Stoneham, MA (9 mi), Melrose, MA (9 mi), North Reading, MA (9 mi), Manchester-by-the-Sea, MA (9 mi), Chelsea, MA (10 mi), Essex, MA (11 mi)

Sirved has 92 restaurant menus for Peabody, Massachusetts. Want a specific cuisine? Check out our best lists for Italian, Mexican or Asian in Peabody. Dietary need? Let us show you all the gluten free, vegetarian or vegan options. Search Sirved for things like burgers 🍔, wings , pizza 🍕, tacos 🌮 and more. Need just a kids menu or drink menu? Sirved categorizes our menus to make exploring easier.

Frequent searches leading to this page
not your in peabody, not your average joe's lunch menu, not your in peabody reviews, not your average joe's in peabody, not your food photos, not your average joe's menu