Menu for ElMar's NY Pizza in Plymouth, MN
-
Open:11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
-
Cuisines:
American North American
American North American
-
Features:
Takeout , Delivery
-
Known for:
Wi-Fi, Casual, Cozy, Quick bite, Beer, Comfort food, Wine, Good for kids, Family-friendly, Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits, Mask required, Staff wear masks, High chairs, Restroom, Gender-neutral restroom, Seating, Outdoor seating, Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Wheelchair accessible restroom, Wheelchair accessible seating, Credit Card Payments, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments, Dine-in, Dinner, Popular Dinner, Lunch, Popular Lunch, Solo dining,Read more
ElMar's NY Pizza in Plymouth, MN, is a sought-after American restaurant, boasting an average rating of 4.7 stars. Here’s what diners have to say about ElMar's NY Pizza. Today, ElMar's NY Pizza will be open from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM. Other attributes on top of the menu include: casual.
Looking for other options with similar menus? Check out Jimmy John's and La Cocina de Ana.
Enjoyed your meal here? Leave a review!
Additional Information
Website
Payment Options
Credit, Debit, Apple Pay, Google Pay
This is a solid top 5 NYC style pie! They have a dozen pies as slice options and also make full pies. We did the full cup & char... pepperoni which was extremely greasy but spot on for what we ordered. The crust is perfect and the sauce and cheese was thecorrect amount and paired perfectly with the crust. I would have picked a less greasy option but was out voted. Only complaintin the dine in is the plates were the paper style which is fine but these were bottom of the barrel and with the grease from thepie soaked right through to the table. Will be back regularly for slices but for full pies will avoid the pepperoni due to thegrease. Highly recommended! Read more
I got a slice of pepperoni/sausage and a slice of the ?garbage? (think supreme plus jalapeño) pizzas. The portions are generous... (I should have ordered 1 slice). My first bite impressed me as the flavors are all fresh and the garlic crust offered a nicecrunch with a burst of flavor. I preferred the pepperoni/sausage to the ?garbage? slice. The wait time is minimal as the pizzasare already made. They just need to heat up the slice. They offer whole 18? pizzas too. My guess is that they take longer toprepare as they are made to order. The venue is modern and inviting, offering an upbeat vibe. The outdoor patio seating will beinviting when the weather finally warms up. It?s a great pizza option whether you want to eat in or take out. Read more
I also learned about this place from Tiktok. My husband and I love NY style pizza so we decided to check it out! We have gotten... it twice in 2 weeks despite it being almost an hour from where we live. We have tried the pizza and wings- wings are MASSIVE!(Well, so is the pizza ????)?.absolutely delicious- highly recommend! Read more
This is hands-down the best NY pizza in the cities. This will go up in my top 5 favorite pizza spots ever. Staff was super... friendly, place was very clean and new and the quality of their food was fantastic. I will definitely be back and will be worththe 30 minute drive it will take me to do so. Bravo, team ElMar, you guys are killing it in the pizza game and I?m glad you?rein MN! Read more
Q & A
Activity Feed
FAQs
When is ElMar's NY Pizza open?
ElMar's NY Pizza is open on the following days:
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Thursday: 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Sunday: 03:00 PM - 07:00 PM
What forms of payment are accepted at ElMar's NY Pizza?
They accept Credit, Debit, Apple Pay and Google Pay at ElMar's NY Pizza.
Does ElMar's NY Pizza offer delivery?
Yes, ElMar's NY Pizza offers delivery.
When you order from this place, you?ll need to make some space?the pies are the size of the moon ???? But you?d can expect... nothing less from a shop called El-Mars? ???? Alrighty, enough cosmic comedy. With noo further ado, here?s some New York stylefor you: Meat Pie ???? ???? ???? House meatballs, cup-and-char pepperoni, fresh sausage, ricotta cheese, white onions, andfresh garlic oil Chicken Parm Pie ???? ???? House red sauce instead of pizza sauce, pecorino, shredded mozzarella, freshmozzarella balls, house breaded chicken cutlet, fresh basil, fresh oregano, and fresh garlic oil Meatball Pie ???????? Housemeatballs, roasted tomatoes, red onions, fresh basil, and fresh garlic oil From ElMar?s on Vicksburg in Plymouth When I tellpeople ?Can?t talk, in a meeting,? this the kind of meat-ing I?m talkin? about ???? The Meat Pie is my to-DIE-for favorite ????The house meatballs are simply little Italian miracles?slightly spicy and super savory?make sure you?re sitting down when youeat this one ???? But it doesn?t end here, because you?ll pro?lly shed a tear when you hit a bite of ricotta ???? No cheese pun,it?s simply unbelievable. And we haven?t gotten to the pepperoni. It?s the kind that cups and crisps for maximum deliciousness,each slice a chalice for fresh garlic oil ???? Boy, this pizza was an experience! ?? Coming in second was the Chicken Parm.Herbaceous, sensatious, and utterly temptatious? ???? shoot, so good its messing with my vocabulary. This one?s meant for meatlovers and cheese huggers who can?t resist this classic poultry/pasta combo ???? And finally, the Meatball pie. Any vegetablefans out there will enjoy the plentiful tomatoes, onions, and basil ???? And y?all know where I fall on the meatballs????????? Here?s a slice of truth: ElMar?s is far from New York, but their pizza is straight outta N.Y. ???? It?s a wholedifferent experience than any other pie, and totally worth a try! Thank you to Jami Doyle and Ethan Clinite for the da Read more