About 20 minute drive from downtown Victoria, Keating is a beautiful quiet community who's pride is the Keating Pizza place. They have the juiciest Hawaiian pizza I've seen yet. It's worth the drive!
Craving pizza, I thought I?d try Keating Pizza for the first time. My cell phone was having issues so I couldn?t call ahead. Once there, I was told it would be about 25 minutes for a medium pizza so I chose 4 slices of pepperoni pizza which is the same size as a medium pizza but more expensive - I paid $26.25! Once home we attempted to eat the slices but couldn?t make it past a few bites each. Worst pizza on the island! They use the cheapest ?pretend? pepperoni, sliced thick and double stacked - it was vile and actually made me nauseous! The sauce was ?passable?, a bit sweet but no bearing on an authentic Italian sauce. Then they piled on cheese overtop everything. The crust was just so-so but there was way too much cheese. An extremely disappointing meal. And it wasn?t cheap either. I will not be returning.
Order a Hawaiian and meat lovers for my birthday yesterday and sitting hear today eating leftovers and its just as good today. Its the best you can get on the island
After hearing the umpteenth commercial for this place I thought I would give it a try. I arrived at approximately 1:30pm no trouble with parking. I ordered three slices: a cheese, a pepperoni and mushroom, and a veggie. Cheese was thick( actually too thick, felt rubbery) and sauce was slightly sweet. As a rule I don't like sweet sauce this wasn't bad but noticeable. Crust was good. Pepperoni and mushroom - a third too much cheese. It over shadowed the pepperoni and the mushrooms were overwhelmed. Again crust was good. Had the best browning on the cheese near the crust of the three slices. Veggie again a third too much cheese, overwhelming the veggies. It was hard to make out what type of veggies were on the slice. Once again crust was good. Cost for three slices $19.95 so an expensive testing. I could give it another star to star and a half if the cheese amount was reduced by a third as a norm. The male staff member was average in service, the female staff member was pleasant/friendly.
picked up a hawaiian large pizza special, I guess because it's the special they don't worry about over cooking it, I still have the burnt dough taste and seriously, like a cardboard cheese topping.. What happened you guys, disgusting
Keating Pizza is the best pizza in Victoria! Not only did I enjoy my Meat Lover's that I ordered on Friday, but when I inadvertently locked my keys in my vehicle, Manager Dan took time out of his busy day to drive me home and back (45 minutes). Who does that these days!! Love you guys!! <3
I really don?t know why I keep coming back here. The slices that are gone weren?t eaten, we placed them on the other side of the box to try and soak up some of the oil. The entire box ended up going into the garbage as I wouldn?t even let my dog eat this stuff. The pizza we got tonight was really sloppy and unappetizing. The dough was either not cooked long enough or there was too much sauce but all the slices in the box are soaked with so much oil that the liner inside the pizza box was soaked through. Every time my partner and I order pizza from here it looks like this. I really don?t know why we thought MAYBE this time it wouldn?t be as gross, but nope. Now we definitely won?t be coming back. What a shame.
The most expensive veggie pizza slice I have ever had. $6.30!? Couldn?t believe it. Thought I?d try it to see if it?s worth the fortune. It was not. Normal sized, barely any toppings, mediocre ingredients. ?Loaded with cheese? they say. At least the staff was very friendly.
We're proud to be from Saanichton and our american is what makes Keating Pizza so great. If you want to try savory pizza then our restaurant is the place for you. Call us at (250) 652-0772 for more info or make a reservation.
Adriana's The Whole Enchilada - mexican (0.08 km)
Keating Coffee - canadian (0.12 km)
Sassy's Family Restaurant - american (1.98 km)
Brentwood Bay Village Empourium - canadian (2.65 km)
Brentwood Bay Brewskys Taphouse - american (2.68 km)