Menu for Mario's in Setauket- East Setauket, NY
-
Open:11:30 AM - 12:00 AM
- Contact:
-
Cuisines:
Italian
Italian
-
Features:
Delivery , Non-Contact Delivery
-
Dietary:
Vegetarian
-
Known for:
Great coffee, Great dessert, Happy hour drinks, Happy hour food, Healthy options, Cozy, Late-night food, Romantic, Upscale, Small plates, Kids menu, Vegetarian options, Wine, Live music, Good for watching sport, Good for kids, Wi-Fi, Casual, Comfort food, Beer, Cocktails, Coffee, Dessert, Dine-in, Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits, Dinner, Mask required, Staff wear masks, Accepts reservations, Hard liquor, Lunch, Bar onsite, Popular Lunch, Catering, Curbside pickup, Fast service, Good for groups, High chairs, Solo dining, Restroom, Seating, Family-friendly, Wheelchair accessible parking lot, LGBTQ+ friendly, Wheelchair accessible restroom, Wheelchair accessible seating, No-contact delivery, Credit Card Payments, Debit cards, Delivery, NFC mobile payments, Takeaway, Popular with Tourists, Wheelchair-accessible entrance, Dinner reservations recommended, Showing the World Cup, Alcohol, Dinner,Read more
Mario's in Setauket- East Setauket, NY, is a sought-after Italian restaurant, boasting an average rating of 4.1 stars. Here’s what diners have to say about Mario's. Today, Mario's is open from 11:30 AM to 11:59 PM. Don’t risk not having a table. Call ahead and reserve your table by calling (631) 751-8840.
Don’t feel like leaving the house? You can order your next meal from Mario's through OpenTable.
Mario's offers all sorts of meals, including vegetarian dietary options.
Ready to try them out? Other attributes include: good for watching sport.
Love the menu, but want to try somewhere new? Try Madiran The Wine Bar and Setauket Gourmet Deli and Catering.
Have you dined here before? Leave a review!
Additional Information
Website
Payment Options
Credit, Debit, Apple Pay, Google Pay
There are currently no photos.
Have been there a few times for drinks, apps and pizza. The food is awesome! Pizza is excellent, exactly the way NY pizza should... be. Also tried pasta with marinara and friends had a chicken dish. All raved. Bar area can get a bit crowded but service isexcellent. Read more
Very comfortable and accommodating. From appetizers, drinks & entrees was on point. We had a great time there.
The food, staff and atmosphere are 2nd to none! Jill the GM and her amazing staff are superb! A real family style Italian... restaurant and with live music too! Make a reservation and you'll be back again and again! Read more
What a beautiful place!!!! The relaxed ambience of the bar/lounge is popular with guests and the live band added to the... excitement of the evening. Not only is the waitstaff adorbs but super sweet!! My girlfriend got the meatballs (5??) my friendgot the Eggplant (5??) my other friend got the claims (5??) and unfortunately I ordered the seasonal veggies and pasta butdoubled the veggies and only half the pasta…. It came backwards, barely any veggies and way too much pasta, pasta was hard andveggies were not steamed properly (2??). The owners are adorable older sweet gentleman who came over to say hello. I woulddefinitely go back and try again, but not the veggie meal??. This place is super cool????????????. Read more
Q & A
Activity Feed
FAQs
When is Mario's open?
Mario's is open on the following days:
Monday: 11:30 AM - 11:59 PM
Tuesday: 11:30 AM - 11:59 PM
Wednesday: 11:30 AM - 11:59 PM
Thursday: 11:30 AM - 11:59 PM
Friday: 11:30 AM - 11:59 PM
Saturday: 11:30 AM - 11:59 PM
Sunday: 11:30 AM - 11:59 PM
What forms of payment are accepted at Mario's?
They accept Credit, Debit, Apple Pay and Google Pay at Mario's.
Does Mario's offer delivery?
Yes, Mario's offers delivery.
Does Mario's offer reservations?
Yes, Mario's accepts reservations.
We used to go to Mario's years ago. This is the first time we've gone since their re-opening. The remodel is nice but the food... was just ok. I also feel it's on the expensive side and we eat out fairly regularly in similar style and class of restaurants.Two adults and a child had a bill of $93. Two chicken dishes ($27 each, ridiculous), 1 child's meal, 1 appetizer (calamari), 1glass of wine, 1 soda = $93 without tip. I know cost's have risen and I'm sure everyone's jumping on the post-covid raise pricesbandwagon, but should a family of three expect a restaurant bill to be $100+ from now on? We are not the typicaleat-out/grub-hub/fast food every day family. We cook at home but every other week or so like to dine out. My real peeve wasn'tso much the bill - I have no problem paying for good food - but I didn't come away saying "that was great". As an example, theChicken Piccata was not the traditional, somewhat loose, delicate lemon-butter-caper pan sauce. Their "sauce" certainly hadcapers, but was basically a lemon-flavored, thick, congealed heavy goop (cornstarch?) that you can lift on a fork. I'm a prettygood cook myself and know my way around the kitchens and was a bit let-down. At $27 for 2 pieces of chicken, are you furthertrying to save money on butter and wine by serving a quasi-Piccata sauce? Come on. And the calamari appetizer at $16 was not agenerous portion. Finally, there was the cute little additional charge for using a credit card. Maybe that's reasonable ifcharging something for under $15, but to pull the additional money grab on a $115 dollar bill (including tip)? The regularcustomers who care more about cocktails will still wait for a table on a Saturday night, so I'm sure this won't affect much. Butas someone who goes to restaurants for good food, I was disappointed first time out. EDIT based on owner reply: Maybe we werecharged $27 for the chicken dishes in error, because when I did the math using $27 per dish it came out to exactly t Read more