After hearing a lot about this place,wanted to try it out. Had to convince our group to have dinner here because we had sonny pizza the other night. No one wanted to have pizza for dinner two nights in a row . But man!! This pizza was awesome . We loved the vegan/vegetarian pizza it was fresh and flavourful full . We also had the pomegranate lemonade which was good. The cheese curds were a let down . Because it was too oily and tasted bland
Their wood-fired pizzas are delicious! All the staff are super nice, and seem to be enjoying themselves and having a great time. Inside atmosphere is nice, a bit on the loud side (due to it being pretty packed), and there is outdoor seating available too.
1st time here, we'll be back. Pizza was delicious. My son and I split the large Fun Guy, lots of flavor and more than expected mushrooms. Great selection of micro brew too.
My first time trying cheese curds and they were mind blowing!!There are various options to customize your pizzas with different toppings .You would want to check out this place if you are ever in Door county.
This was great! The waiter was very tentative to us, and even gave us a free piece of cheesecake when we told him it was our 2nd anniversary. The staff was very upbeat and personable.
While in Sister Bay we came across Wild Tomato and we decided to give it a shot. And we were glad we did. My wife and my youngest ordered the Deluxe pizza and my middle and I ordered the old school pizza while my oldest went with pepperoni. The pizzas according to EVERYONE was that they were the best pizzas we have ever had. Even being a wood fired pizza they still had a delicate soft texture to the crust. The ingredients were amazingly fresh. We will definitely be back the sooner the better. Simply amazing!! Well done Wild Tomato excellent food and excellent service as well!!
When someone told us to check out the best pizza place they had ever been to, I wasn't really excited because I grew up in Chicago so i've had my share of great pizza. We decided to give it a try and I am so glad we did! I got the Green and Gold sans meat and I dipped it in ranch! Wow. I was so excited that I got to try this incredible pizza. I took leftovers all the way back to Central IL! Go Pack Go! :)
First I started with cheese curds, wow perfection! Then got the old school very delicious! (BBQ chicken, and onions) my favorite type, Tried the margarita it was pretty good but not as good as the old school just my opinion but probably because I?m comparing it to my favorite pizza flavor. My only slight negative while the pizza was amazing the crust at the very end needs a little flavor and the ranch is definitely needed when it comes to crust by its self but overall really really delicious
Foodies ahoy! At Wild Tomato Wood-fired Pizza and Grille we provide an amazing culinary experience in Sister Bay. Our experienced chefs have worked hard to bring you amazing food.
Bier Zot - european (0 mi)
Stabbur Beer Garden at Al Johnson's - canadian, american (0.06 mi)
Grasse's Grill - american (0.07 mi)
CHOP - american (0.07 mi)
Al Johnson?s Swedish Restaurant & Butik - swedish (0.09 mi)