Menu for Mill Supper Club in Sturgeon Bay, WI

Visited on the evening of July 4th. First of all, the positives. The bar service and drinks were excellent. The wait time was... reasonable. Now the not so good. The food quality was just so-so. The waitresses we had can be best described by the word?slow?. She was friendly, but inattentive. I am aware that this restaurant has an excellent reputation, but at this point theycan best be best described as overrated. Read more

we had all you can eat chicken,you get a lot of mashed potatoes stuffing and coleslaw the chicken was a little dry but it still... tasted good was a little upset that the waitress charged for four full chicken dinners when I told her my children are onlygoing to eat one piece each of chicken. They should probably just charge a plate charger something for children. Read more

Excellent fish prime rib on Saturday night is fantastic and wonderful people behind the bar

It's great food with all you can eat on certain days. Some days its fish,prime rib chicken. They have cheese and crackers... while you wait for your dinner call them first to see if they are open now Read more

Great classic supper club fare but a little light on the normal accoutrements in the relish tray area. Nice touch with the... crackers and cheese spread though. The dinner service was prompt and helpful. Unfortunately we had a miss with a brandy oldfashioned sweet drink order. It was very lacking in the sweet area, almost seltzery and when I brought back to the bar, theysaid they had no simple syrup to add (!?) and I had them add more white soda instead. It was better but not right, I should havehad them remake it in hindsight. I don't know what happened there. Our table just had waters the rest of the night. The placewas good and seemed to have a mix of locals and visitors, which is always a good sign. Read more