• Open:
    11:00 AM - 09:00 PM (CDT)
  • Cuisine

    Mexican

  • Features

    Patio , Takeout , Delivery , Non-Contact Takeout

  • Dietary

    Vegetarian

Google Reviews

Adrianne Olsen

The food was excellent! Guacamole was the best I?ve had. Margaritas was amazing. Definitely will be visiting again

Colleen Tarver

I did not expect to find authentic Mexican food in WI but I did. The Guacamole was made fresh at the table and was amazing. As you can see, it didn't last long.

Robert B.

Margaritas were very good. The chips and salsa came out with the chips smelling of rancid old oil. The waiter took them and returned with new chips that were much better. Then the food came out quickly- maybe a bit too quickly as the plates were hot but the food was cold. The service was good, but overall not a good experience.

Maryanne Carmony

Our first time in the area and happened to stop for lunch. So glad we did. The service and food was outstanding! Loved the guacamole cart! Guacamole made fresh right in front of you. So delicious. Margaritas were great! I would highly recommend this restaurant.

Kelly marquardt

We ordered margaritas and never imagined how big they would be and so good. Then a waiter came to the table asked if we wanted guacamole and he made it at the table, so fresh. I had street tacos and my husband had fajitas. The portions where large and we probably should of shared. Both meals where prepared and seasoned well. Like many places this restaurant was short staffed but you would never of known it because the service was spot on. It was our birthdays and we couldn?t of been happier with the experience at this restaurant.

Kelly Marquardt

It was my husband birthday and my birthday weekend and what a great place to celebrate. It?s been about 3 years since I have had a strawberry margarita so I ordered a medium and my husband a large. Holy wow they where huge, and very delish. Then they have a waiter come to the table and ask if you want fresh guacamole. The guacamole is so fresh and made for a great appetizer. I got street tacos and my husband fajitas. I think we should of shared. Large portions and the meat was very tender along with great flavor. They where short staffed like a lot of places but they did a fantastic job and made sure we where taken care of. It?s nice to write a positive review. It makes us want to come back.

J Deterville

My favorite place in sturgeon bay!!! I go every time I'm there. Food is awesome, staff is great, bathrooms are nice.

Jeff Anderson

This place was amazing! Crazy good Mexican food. Some little kid made the guacamole fresh, after we ordered it. Probably the best guac we've ever had. Prices were very good, $50 for 3 people & the guac. Pictures of street tacos, shrimp tacos, & guacamole.

More Google Reviews

Mexican like never before. Be sure to join Old Mexico Cantina and Grill in Sturgeon Bay to explore their mouthwatering food. Try their tasty salads and open your world to new experiences. Bring in the family or grab a few friends and feel free to check out their menu. Call them at (920) 818-1500.

Wanda Jean's Family Restaurant - american (0.05 mi)
5th and Jefferson Coffee House - american (0.51 mi)
Crate Restaurant - american (0.66 mi)
Inn at Cedar Crossing - american (0.68 mi)
Trattoria Dal Santo - italian (0.7 mi)

Towns near Sturgeon Bay
Egg Harbor, wi (14 mi), Algoma, wi (17 mi), Baileys Harbor, wi (17 mi), Fish Creek, wi (21 mi), Menominee, MI (22 mi), Marinette, wi (22 mi), Ephraim, wi (24 mi), Peshtigo, wi (24 mi)

Sirved has 50 restaurant menus for Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin. Want a specific cuisine? Check out our best lists for Mexican, Italian or Asian in Sturgeon Bay. Dietary need? Let us show you all the gluten free, vegetarian or vegan options. Search Sirved for things like burgers 🍔, sushi 🍣, pizza 🍕, tacos 🌮 and more. Need just a kids menu or drink menu? Sirved categorizes our menus to make exploring easier.

Frequent searches leading to this page
old mexico cantina and grill in sturgeon bay review, menu for old mexico cantina and grill, old mexico cantina and grill menu photos, old mexico cantina and grill lunch menu, old mexico in sturgeon bay, old mexico in sturgeon bay