Menu for Wylder Hotel Tilghman Island in Tilghman, MD

Property is lovely but food needs a SERIOUS adjustment in either cost or quality. Very poor food for way too much money. ... Locals, guests, they all tell me the same. Kitchen staffing needs a major revamp. Read more

Amazing location with laid-back vibe! If you're looking to get away, go outside, and unplug, WYLDER IS THE PLACE! Spent a... weekend away with my S/O at Wylder and had the most amazing time! We had read some reviews before we booked and are so happy wewent for it and booked!! Knowing it is a historic property, the room renovations surpassed all of our expectations! We wereexpecting more of an old B&B with thinking of it as a historic property, but it was really a minimal, nautical beach vibe. Weloved the basics and had everything we needed for comfort! Also, having so much to do outside on the property was amazing so wewere only in our room to sleep. The water does have a smell, but when I asked the front desk about it they explained that it ishow most water in the area is. We experienced the same water at a few other places we visited during our trip, so it was nothingagainst the hotel. I was curious about the water since I've never been to the area before and my S/O was embarrassed I asked thehotel about it. But, they were understanding and offered an explanation without making me feel like a Karen for asking! Everytime we approached a staff member, they were so helpful! From stopping and grabbing ice for us (and even filling a small coolerbag!) to personally bringing us fresh towels when we called later at night because housekeeping had left for the day. This,again, was not the experience we were expecting based on some of the reviews so we were blown away by their service. Sorry forthose people who caught the staff on an off-day, but we had amazing experiences the whole time we were here. Definitelyrecommend! Read more

The Wylder Hotel was an oasis on the hot day we went there. The pool was refreshing as was the complimentary Champagne. The... crabs at the restaurant were smallish, but good. High prices. Read more

Be glad you read this before you go there: Receptionist was extremely rude and unfriendly, the room smelled moldy, staff and... employees in this hotel were rude as well. The pool was disappointing, the water was warm and filthy. The first day we gotthere there was no food to be found. The food they offered for breakfast was also underwhelming; and they charged $20 forbreakfast which consisted of food that looked like it had been sitting out for days.???? They will not tell you where it’scomplimentary or not since the food is not all that I guarantee you will be disappointed if visit this place if you arecelebrating any special occasion don’t come here Read more

First 2 days felt low key relaxing. We were greeted with champagne, and staff to escort us to our bungalow and explain the... property accommodations. All of the chairs around the property were very cozy and we relaxed by the fire pits at night.Restaurant and bar staff were very friendly and helpful. Food and drinks were delicious. The pool staff were fun, checked on usfrequently, and kept the drinks coming, which was appreciated. The water sport equipment was a fun inclusion however there weremore kayaks than paddles available and the paddles were broken. People had to use SUP paddles for kayaks and it was awkward. Itwould be helpful if the equipment was more thoroughly checked and replaced as needed so guests can use as intended. On our finalmorning, we reserved spots for the yoga class and a time slot for sauna use. Unfortunately both were a flop. The front staffdidn’t seem to show any initiative when multiple groups asked for follow up about the yoga instructor’s late arrival/ noshow or location for class. Then when we went to our reserved time for the sauna, it was completely off. Front staff turned onand said “5 minutes” however an hour passed and the sauna was still not ready for use. Unfortunately our checkout timecame, ending our stay here and we were unable to use the sauna. I expressed my concerns with the receptionist at checkout andthey responded with a frowny face and “oh” before taking a phone call. No attempt for service recovery unfortunately so weleft feeling disappointed. I think Wylder’s boutique hotel has an amazing vision but it felt more like dream vs reality. Iwould recommend, following up with staff before reservations to ensure follow through and execution of the events and amenities,so other plans are not delayed throughout your day. I just want future guests to have a full experience. Read more