Reviews for Goodfella's Pizzeria in Afton, OK
Food was very good and staff was super friendly despite me ordering 30 minutes before closing on a busy weekend. Hope they add... aa Alfredo chicken spinach bacon pizza in the future Read more
Goodfellas is a small pizza place less than 2 miles from a small community I am visiting on Grand Lake. There aren't many... options around here, and I didn't have high expectations going in. I was pleasantly surprised with the service, quality andflavor of the pizza and wings we ordered. I had the bacon cheeseburger pizza on gluten free crust, which was crisp and loadedwith toppings. My family tried "The Hoffa" "The Boss" and "The Hitman". Everyone was impressed with the flavor, but especiallyimpressed by the thin crust as it was crisp throughout and not burnt on the edges. Read more
Super yummy pizza with good prices.
I ordered the gluten free pizza and hands down it was the best I've had anywhere ! I highly recommend it. The staff was fun and... pleasant !! Read more
Best pizza on the lake. Professional . even better now. Putting their customers first even during this pandemic. If you have... not tried them yet you must.your gonna Love um???????? Read more
Visiting Marina in Cleora, ordered delivery at 8pm on saturday. Got the medium boss and large "cheese sticks"... $25.00. Asked... for delivery and she made it sound like a big deal to switch it from takeout even tho I said delivery to begin with. (They r 2minutes from here) Delivery made total $30.00 Pizza came in 20 mins tops, cold as leftovers.. and we didnt get our Cheesesticks...we got cheesy bread..can kinda understand that.. And the worst...found a hair. Not mine. Wasnt worth risking therona... Read more
Wonderful pizza and friendly staff. Worth driving way off our route to go to! Definitely would come here again!
Pretty darn good pizza. Give it a try and help a local business.