Reviews for Trecaso's™ Mary Coyle® Fine Italian Cuisine & Ice Cream in Akron, OH

Went expecting to eat in restaurant, that is NOT the case. Disappointed that their online ordering only supports delivery... option, not pickup! My spaghetti sauce tasted burnt, meatballs were tough! This is NOT the Trecaso experience I remember. Read more

The food is good. But since Covid. He's locked customer outside. You have to go in to order. And that's when he barks... DID... YOU LOOK AT THE MENU?? The ice cream is good. But everything is to go. Instead of a half gallon container he gives you twoChinese takeout containers and stuffs with ice cream. Who does that? Read more

There ice cream is Absolutely Amazing ???? The people around are also Fanominal. I just LOVE being around the Square. Keep up... the Great Work ???????????? Read more

Had a good experience. Checked out the menu outside, ordered inside, and waited outside for our food. We split a cheese pizza,... which was really good! Then had the peanut butter banana bowl; it was incredible! First off, it was massive. I would recommendsplitting it with someone! It was vanilla ice cream with peanut butter and marshmallow sauce with peanuts and banana. Pureperfection! Read more

Been coming here since I was 9 years old in the 1950?s. The Ice Cream is still the same! Their ice cream menu offerings are the... same! The best Ice Cream sodas, shakes, and Sundae?s hands down! My favorite is the Cherry Soda, with the original cherryphosphate! Yum! Read more

Such a wonderful place to get ice cream. The inside is beautiful. Throw back to the old days. The employees are really nice and... patient. Read more

This is the real deal, an old time ice cream parlor with great sundaes. My wife always gets the tin roof sundae with Spanish... peanuts. This place is very authentic but be forewarned. Stick to the ice cream and sundaes and sweets. The food is just okayand that?s being generous. Indulge your sweet tooth but eat your main course elsewhere. Definitely worth a trip for theatmosphere and sundaes. Read more

Went here based on a recommendation from my nephew. This was the best little retro ice cream/pizza shop that has AWESOME ... meatball subs. The service was great. The decor was 50-60's which was fitting and very well maintained. The mocha chip icecream was out of this world. I will definitely make the drive to come back to try their pizza and a different ice cream flavor. There's convenient parking right next to the building and outdoor seating. Read more