Reviews for Brother's NY Style Pizza West Albany in Albany, GA

I've tried the pizza and the Parmesan chicken with a nice side salad and garlic bread knot which was delicious. I plan on trying... other dishes and most of it's affordable with generous portions. Check them out soon! Read more

The food is always good (except for the gizzards I got the other night). But the customer service from the young girl who was... working Friday, Oct. 14, 2022 at 1:50 pm. She took my call-in order and was friendly but by the time I got here to pick up myfood something apparently had happened because you could hear her yelling from the back. A young man informed her that acustomer (me) was at the register and she said she?ll have to wait. He eventually came and I paid for my order and he brought myfood out. The young man was very friendly and kept apologizing. He even held the door open for me to go out. Just my experience? Read more

People are great, best service I've had since the whole pandemic. Wife is from NY I've eaten a lot of pizza... Not sure how... authentic it is to ny pizza, maybe different region. But the pizza is top notch. Very good.. best and closest I've been to...Will return.... Read more

Corn nugget and orka was right on point kids love the wings calzone was full of flavor, the owner was willing to make anything... right that we didn?t like but everything was great Read more

I wanted SO BAD for my pizza to be as good as NY pizza (I had just returned from a vacay to NY), but?it?just?wasn?t... ????????!?! The taste of the pizza (Deluxe Cheese Pizza) had good flavor, but the structure of it was?not like NY pizza. We wentto tear some slices off, but it kinda just fell apart(see pic). I had ordered online (3pm) for a later pick-up(5:15). It almostSEEMED like it was made at order time & possibly just sat until our pickup (not sure?but the pizza was warm at best) ?!? Iwanted to give 3 stars (& probably should), but the restaurant was clean & the Christian music was uplifting ! Maybe, the nexttime I?m in town I?ll have to try eating in next time, because I do LOVE some NY pizza !?! ???????????? Read more

I hate to give 3 stars but I'm being completely honest here.. it all looks great but it was not that good. My pizza and corn... nuggets were not cooked all the way and just tasted bland. AND I asked for pineapple on my pizza and it's clearly not there.Thebanana pudding was just okay. I've heard so many good things about this place so I will definitely try again and re-review. I'mhoping it's what everyone says it is next time. Read more

One of the best pizzas I had in a while! Check out Brothers NY style pizza. Quality ingredients and piping hot all the way... through! The dough is out of this world made from scratch! Great job guys?! Read more

Restaraunt was clean and the staff members were all courteous. I went for the calzone. I ordered the small and it was just the... right size for me. The large must be pretty impressive. The ingredients all seemed very fresh and tasted great. I'll have totry the stuffed pizza on my next visit. Read more