Reviews for Cavallario's Steak & Seafood in Alexandria Bay, NY
To start with, we did get a table early, we did get our first drinks quickly and we waited 30 mins for appetizer which was... overpriced and sparingly and presentation was lousy not quality. It took an hour and 42 mins until we got our main order withoutinforming us for a long wait.. we ordered Ribeye and were served cheap dry sirloin steak and did not taste seasoned for a 36$steak!!!! And there was no AC, I overheard the lady to turn on and off the AC in a very hot weather !!! We had to let them knowthat there was an option for fries for kids if they will add on again extra dollar to our order. . and worst the food was nothot at all for a 180$ !!! It's very disappointing and upsetting and no salad for the meal but and still have to add on for extra2.99 and mashed potatoes were warm, my goodness! It wasn't worth it!!! WOULD NOT RECOMMENT THIS PLACE! Read more
Came here during the Pirate Weekend festivities and it was busy!! We had drinks and appetizers which were very good!! The... staff was very professional even though it was crazy. We went into the bar after adding our names to the wait list and foundseats immediately so we ate there and enjoyed watching all the people. All apps were excellent choices from the menu. We willdefinitely be back while visiting the area! Read more
We enjoyed this place so many times, many years ago, but since the restaurant was taken over by the current owner it has been a... major disappointment. We decided to give it another chance this summer, after a disappointing evening the summer before covid. Regrettably, with the same result. The meatballs were likely from last season, tasted metallic and freezer burnt. The marinarasauce on the chicken parm was acidic and just plain awful. The only few good wines on the list weren't available, which issurprising given it was early in the summer season. The renovation looks like it ran out of money. The atmosphere is like a1970's cafeteria only with carpet (from the 70's). I kept waiting for the ceiling tiles to fall on our table. It's unfortunatethat the owner comes on here and like someone else said, behaves belligerently. You'd think he would use the criticism toperhaps improve things a little. When, as a couple, you drop $130+ on a dining experience, you really hope for more. We willnever be back, which I'm certain the owner will have a cheeky response to. Read more
This place is amazing!! My husband and I ate here a few weeks ago, and will be making the 45 minute drive to eat dinner here... again tonight! Food was absolutely delicious! The bartender made my special request drink flawlessly. Scallops were cooked toperfection, steak was the perfect rare. Don?t even get me started on the bread. Staff is friendly and attentive. We?re going tohave to make this a once a month outing!!! Read more
Unbelievable food and service...I had prime rib and my wife had crab legs we also had French onion soup. The Prime Rib was the... best I have had in a very long time... This place is a must have when in this area... Read more
We thought we were walking into a 1970s eatery and expected to see Dirk Diggler but the place was updated and had great food and... service. The escargot was cooked perfectly along with the scallops. The calamari was good but did not expect a spicy sauce. Service ?bartender? was great! Read more
Popular place for good reason. Prime rib is perfectly prepared and huge -- pictured is the smaller cut. Also the duck was... excellent. A must stop for visitors to Alexandria Bay. Read more
We had a great meal and great service when we went with a group of 8. Everyone enjoyed their drinks and meals. Most of us... ordered various steaks and they were all delicious and cooked perfect. Some had seafood and they also enjoyed their dishes.Soups,salads and apps all were tasty as well. It's a steak house people so don't complain about the prices which I thought forthe quality of the food and service was right on par. Will come back again next time in the area. Read more