Reviews for Peppino's Pizzeria & Sports Grille in Allendale, MI

I got the grilled salmon which came with potatoes and a seasonal vegetable (green beans). It was absolutely amazing and... completely worth the price. Read more

Used to like their breadsticks & pizza, but they must?ve changed them in the last month. breadsticks are hard & flavorless, the... meat on the pizza tasted burnt & dried out. Can?t taste pizza sauce, only the thin, burnt crust & smallest amount of cheese. Read more

Three strikes and you?re out! Seeing as Allendale has very limited dining restaurants available, it?s very disappointing that... this one is consistently a bad experience. The first bad visit was when we found out that they changed the recipe for the bbqchicken pizza which was our favorite. They changed it to a homemade bbq sauce that is more like a hot wing sauce.The second timewe asked for a chocolate milk for my son. He couldn?t get anything out of the straw when he tried sucking on it. Long storyshort after trying to stir the drink we ended up finding out the hard way that the milk was sour. When we tried to tell ourserver he agreed but when the manager came over we were treated like we were trying to get a free meal instead of warning themthat they had a bad gallon of milk in their fridge. We still to this day don?t think that they threw that gallon away thatnight. Lastly today we went for breakfast. Our intention was to try the breakfast buffet, but when we got there is wascompletely picked over. There was some sausage patties, but they were burnt and dried out. They don?t have a breakfast menu sothere is no substitute if you aren?t feeling how the buffet looks. As I said it very disappointing when a restaurant like I?mthis is consistently bad. We are unfortunately writing this place off and discouraging anyone from eating there. Read more

Came in here with a large youth team and the staff was able to put us all together in the Loft area without having to wait. I... might add that we did not give them any notice either as we just stumbled upon this restaurant. The pizza was perfect- greatsauce, toppings, and not too heavy. The chicken wings had the best tasting sauce I think I've had outside of Memphis. We willdefinitely be back very soon!!! Read more

Great service. Food was delicious. Enjoyed the experience very much.

This is a great restaurant! Delicious food and a friendly staff make for an enjoyable place to eat. My family and I will... definitely be back. Update: I have been back several times since my original review. Most recently, my daughter and I stopped inon a Tuesday evening for dinner. We shared the cheesy breadsticks as an appetizer (only $6 during happy hour). The appetizercould be a meal in itself! It's a good-sized garlicky cheese pizza with no pizza sauce. My daughter had the loaded mac and cheesminus the bacon, and I had the meaty five cheese pizza minus the meat. Both of us are vegetarians. We both enjoyed the food, andwe had plenty of leftovers. Read more

Not only are the wings crispy on the outside and deliciously tender on the inside, I was surprised to find their Korean BBQ... sauce as well as their Buffalo sauce to be a perfect match to such a tasty appetizer. I always get the cheesy breadsticks, andtheir sauce is spot on perfection. The cannoli here are also delectable, and they have a sweet finish that leaves the taste budssinging. Their service and cleanliness of the restaurant is also exceptional. Mitch was very pleasant throughout the entiremeal. I genuinely felt welcome and was very pleased with my overall experience here. I cannot give more stars to thisrestaurant, but if you haven't tried Peppino's, you need to. You can believe I'll be back. Read more

We were served chicken wings with feathers still attached, and what appears to be a human hair as well. Our server politely... asked if we would like to speak to the manager and we said yes please. The manager never came to speak with us, the server justreturned and said she could comp that specific portion of our meal. Read more