Reviews for Allendale Steakhouse in Allendale, NJ
Steak was unbelievable. Porterhouse for 3 was amazing every bite melts in your mouth. Table service was great.
Best steak in Bergen county, Cajun ribeye is the way to go. I met the owner Eddie, a true gentleman!
Third time there, what a great place. Staff is friendly and the steak, we get the Porterhouse for 4, is outstanding. I'm a... butcher and I can say that the meat they use is some of the best I have ever had. I'm never disappointed. I just wish the had ababy Porterhouse for dessert.. you know you had a good steak when nothing is left on your plate....byob is an added bonus. Read more
This is a BYOB steakhouse, outdoor and indoor dinning and attentive service. The portions were large and many take a leftovers... home. The steaks were tender and properly prepared. Read more
4.5/ 5 - Went for dinner service on a weekend. There is limited restaurant parking but street parking is available. BYOB with a... liquor store across the street. Reservations are highly recommended. Service was ok. Only had the Porterhouse, which was greatand I would order again. Price point is fair for the quality of steak. Possibly the best steak I’ve had in the area. Read more
Stay away. The restaurant was highly recommended. I am not sure where to start about this lackluster place. The only good thing... was a perfect temperature of San Pellegrino. Caesar salad was wilted, smelled of fish (I guess I am not just a fan of anchovydressing). We returned it. We ordered medium Sirloin ($50). On the first try it came just rare to raw. On the second try it cameout as medium rare to rare. The waiter told us that we don’t get the idea as it was prepared 5 star chef and we shouldn’tdoubt it. This comment stands out as quite rude. We didn’t touch the meat. Asked for a check. Any decent place I have been atleast would try to make up for the horrendous experience, but not them. Just stay away, you can get a better steak and servicein any steak chain. Read more
Meh, The wedge salad was very good and the bacon lardons were fabulous. There is a great sear on the steaks, but any flavor is... coming from the ton of butter that they use, the mashed potatoes were flavorless and the brussel sprouts were nearly raw. Wewere there at 4 on a Sunday and were the only people there and still the service was abysmal. See the photo of the stacked dirtydishes that sat on the table for at least 15 minutes before I finally got up to look for our server who was always on hisphone. He never smiled, never filled our water, never checked on how we liked the food and never came over to the table to cleanup or take our order unless we went to find him.The shrimp in the seafood tower tasted like iodine and we had to spit it out. Read more
You get what you pay for! Amazing place amazing ribeye. Amazing service. Will be back for sure