Reviews for I Love NY Pizza in Alpharetta, GA
After leaving NY for Georgia three years ago, I never thought I would experience the greatness of New York pizza AGAIN. But, on... this fateful Thursday, I found I Love NY Pizza. Oh my god! This is the best pizza I have had in three years since coming to theBig Peach from the Big Apple. From the kind, wonderful staff of servers and chefs to the wonderful Hawaiian pizza, for which thewaiters were ANYTHING BUT careless on the toppings. I only went into the place before going to the ATM, and I didn't break thebank AT ALL! Ayd?n ÇET?N is right, the pizzas are great and the calzones are HUGE! Love it. Yasss!!!!! Will be returningtomorrow, and the day after that! Read more
Two stars because the pizza is edible. This is a third tier pizza comparable to Papa John?s or Dominos. NY Pizza is misleading,... 2nd Tier would be Johnny?s Pizza, 1st Tier Mama?s Pizza in Alpharetta. Gyro should not be on the menu at a Pizzeria. I thinkRed Barron Pizza is better, you can get it inside the Publix next door. Or go to a Kroger they make a better pizza that?sfresh. Read more
Completed a pickup order. Got it home and the Food was tolerable. Ordered garlic cheese bread and the cheese was barely melted,... bread not remotely toasted. Got 2 small meatballs in a huge container. Pizza order was wrong and barely baked. Definitely willnot order again. Stopped getting food from grrr for the same reason a long time ago. They haven?t changed. Read more
We stumbled on this restaurant a couple of weeks ago ?.and today we drove 45 mins just to come back. Best pizza!!! Everything... is hand made and we haven?t found anything close elsewhere. The crust is amazing. Taking extra home :). Read more
This place has great p?zzas and huge calzones, as well as strombol??s. Th?s ?s a p?ct?re of the strombol? I ordered. 5 stars and... w?ll return. Read more
When I tasted the pizza once in Italy, I still remembered the taste of pizza I ate in Rome, both of them superb delicious. Amo... la pizza italiana.. Today I found the same taste .. I LOVE NY pizza Read more
Pizza was average and got less than stellar service. It smelled good when I went in but it was like they didn't want me. When I... called on the pizza he puts me on hold for like 5 minutes. He just put the phone down and could hear them goofing off in theback. Anyway average pizza and the pizza was cooked on time. I spent 36 dollars on 3 large pizzas. Read more
I honestly dont get the good reviews others have posted. Makes me suspect of reviewers. Staff appeared to be bothered by us... being there, and were unfriendly. The young girl who took our order mumbled, had her head resting on her hand and clearly didntwant to be there. We corrected her 3 times on the pizza we wanted, and it was still not what we ordered. We (party of 2) werethe only people inside on a friday night at 6:30. Not only was the order incorrect, but the pizza was under cooked, the saucehad no flavor at all, and the crust was very chewy. Interesting that a father & young child came in to pick up a to go orderand the child said ?dad it stinks in here?. That should have given us a clue it wasnt going to be good. Honestly I dont knowwhy I gave them 2 stars. Very disappointed and will not go back. Read more