Reviews for Main Street Tavern in Amagansett, NY
Lovely evening at this restaurant. The food was very good, and presentation perfect. The staff is very friendly and down to... earth. We will definitely return, when we travel to this area! ???? Read more
Had a beautiful lunch today at Main Street Tavern. From the delicious food to the strong drinks, my group had an enjoyable time.... Would definitely come back next time I?m in town! Read more
The Tavern is my go to dinner spot. The service is always above par and the food goes above and beyond. Danielle and Stephanie... always make our visits special and we will continue to return. Read more
Wow! A tavern with the best food I had in the Montauk - Amagqnsett area, hands down! All fresh and luscious. I had the homemade... chicken pot pie, which was out of this world. My wife had the burger- like no other burger she had, her words. The fries werealso like no other with a puffy shape of happiness in each bite. To end it all was a spectacular, homemade apple cobbler withvanilla ice cream. Insane. Not a slice of apple pie with ice cream but a homemade dish you cannot ship when you gothere. Remember, we all have two stomachs, one for food and one for dessert, lol. So how much was all of this? Extremelyreasonable and below most places that were horrible in Montauk. I personally have my compliments to the chef and may go there onmy way home tomorrow. Don?t let Tavern fool you, it?s too notch! Sorry I ate the food too quick for pictures but you see halfthe apple cobbler. Read more
Dog Friendly!! Great atmosphere, 2 hour parking lot behind the restaurant. Pictures of the Crispy shrimp and zucchini Fritters... both perfect!(and the pupper, not edible????) Read more
Me and my boyfriend were looking where to go for dinner, and we randomly saw this place at Google maps, we were a little... skeptical because of how not many reviews it has, but decided to give it a try! And oh I?m so happy we did! This place has anice & cozy atmosphere/interior, fish tacos are SO GOOD! The crab special was amazing! Cocktails are smooth and tasty! Thisplace is definitely worth a visit! Read more
Amazing food, amazing staff, and covid safe. The steak sandwich is incredible and loved the special spare ribs dish we had.... (Also cocktails were amazing). In summary, I suggest you go! Read more
A random lunch here on Labor Day turned out to be splendid. Clam toast, I think? It was fantastic. Crispy shrimp ? ORDER THIS.... Even the cheeseburger was great, a perfect medium. Highly recommend! Read more