Reviews for Four Brothers Pizza Inn in Amenia, NY
Absolutely disgusting and poor presentation of food. I called and was told the owner, John would call me and he never did. ... This is what they serve and charge $14.95. Read more
We sometimes eat outdoors as they welcome dogs and they are pet friendly. The staff is nice and friendly. The service efficient.... If you stick to their Italian specialties, the food is really excellent. I like their pizza very much. The lasagna tastes verygood, and is my favorite, but is a bit too runny for me. We had the lobster rolls and they were a bit pricy for what you get.Overall, this is a great place. Affordable, home-cooked Italian, made fresh and wonderfully cooked. They know how to make asuperb marinara. Parking is easy on their big lot. Read more
The Shrimp scampi appetizer is amazing! The pizza was the best I've had in years. We ate on the patio. This is such a fun and... unique place.We drove for about 1.5 hours to get there. Worth the trip and we will definitely make this a regular thing. Highlyrecommended.!! Read more
Had a great experience and loved their Lobster Roll !! The "Drive In" area is great for little ones. Very family friendly...you... can even rent out one of their Airstreams for the night !! Read more
Excellent crispy base pie style pizza. Dough was soft and crust was crispy. Great pizza with fresh ingredients. The lasagna was... satisfying and tasty. Didn?t have much meat but the rich cheesy sauce made up for it. The lasagna sheets were somewhatthick. Overall a nice friendly place for a Friday evening meal. Warm, helpful staff. Read more
First off I want to say they serve the appropriate amount of salad dressing for you to add to your salad. I didn?t have to ask... for extra and I added as much as I wanted. The dressing was good, similar to Olive Garden, as was the salad itself. The came outquickly. It was good, better than expected, being at a movie theater, but not a place I would go to unless I was seeing a movie.I had the spanakopita, my boyfriend had the chicken gyro. We also had mozzarella sticks which were really good. I?d be temptedto get two orders to go to nom on while watching the movie. Read more
Dropping my daughter off at camp and stopped for local quick bite and found this place. Basic food nothing special but nothing... ?bad?. Restaurant depot food warmed up. Pizza was fresh but was not a fan of the sauce but the crust was nice a soft texturewise. Quick and easy but not worth price. Read more
Let me start with the fact that I am not a huge fan of four brothers pizza. Its not bad, just different style. Service was... terrific. They accommodated a group of eight on very short notice. Even more surprising was this extremely picky group of peoplehad not one issue with their food. I will end with the fact that this trip let me experience their pizza in a new light. Get themeat lovers, it was awesome. Read more