Reviews for Anderson's Frozen Custard in Amherst, NY

Since moving out of NY many years ago, I have not had a good Beef on Weck in a long time. I must say, theirs is amazing! I had... one and an order of fries with gravy. The Beef was juicy, roll tasted fresh, and any place that has hot gravy that you can servewith a fork because it's so thick, has my vote! My wife had the bbq beef sandwich was the best she ever had. I like thateverything was made fresh when I ordered it and the wait wasn't long at all. Topped it all off with some ice cream, which wasalso delicious. I would not only recommend this place but plan on returning whenever we're in the area. Read more

The chicken sandwich and roast beef sandwiches were delicious and full of flavor. The fries were hot and the drive thru worker... was very pleasant. The Reece pieces sundae is an excellent ice cream option. There is also plenty of parking and space to eatinside. Prices are higher than average for ice cream, but it?s nice to have great food and dessert choices at the same place. Read more

We're at this location at least once a week. My son LOVES their chicken tenders! I'd have to agree: they're fresh, hot (temp),... all white meat. Another favorite of his are the curly Q fries. Their roast beef sandwich is amazing too. Read more

Only had soft serve ice cream, so I can't comment on anything else. Small cone was on what I would have considered a baby cone,... and quantity was equivalent to that as well. Price was in line with small cone prices at other shops. Quality was very good,but overall I was disappointed. Service was OK. 4 stars is hoping that the food continues to be above average. Read more

Always visit here. They have ice cream and food. Never tried the drive thru. Got a root beer milkshake, this was made with root... beer syrup not from the fountain and the Choco Peanut Butter Passion. Lots of indoor and outdoor seating. Multiple registers toplace order. Variety of food, drinks and ice cream flavors. Employees are nice and quick. Read more

The ice cream cake had a very different and eye catching design! It also tasted very good! My first time buying an ice cream... cake from Anderson?s; I?ll definitely be back! Read more

The ice creams are ok. The bubble gum flavor had some gum pieces that are very hard to chew. The Oreo ice cream had tons of... cookies which was nice, but the one with pretzels just a couple of pieces and the ice cream didn?t taste like much. Read more

Clean, kid friendly. Make your own salad and vegan burger was delicious. Had the cookie dough ice cream pie... was hoping for a... full crust, no cookie dough chunks in the actual ice cream but was still tasty. I like that they had healthier food options,soup had sweet potato in it. Nitrate free bacon. Read more