Reviews for Scotch 'N Sirloin in Amherst, NY
We attended dinner with a family of 6, ordering steaks, fish, and several children's meals. The service was incredibly slow. The... waiter and kitchen staff spent more time talking at the window with each other than they did with patrons. They were out of milkwhen requested for the children. When I asked the host about how long our meals would be after waiting over 1 hour for foodthere was no explanation, no apology. Shortly after asking about it the food appeared, likely having been sitting waiting to beserved. The fish was overcooked, vegetables cold and bland. The twice baked potato had no flavor and the filling of it was notproperly mixed (grainy and lumpy, and no add-ins that would normally be seen in the side). The salad bar looked picked over, wedidn't bother with adding it as it was simply lettuce and some dressing with a few other bits, mostly empty bowls. The steak wasflavorful and tender, and was the only redeeming part of the meal. No one asked us how the food was, and no one apologized forthe wait. Not recommended. Save your money and go somewhere else. Read more
In the years that I have been dining at the Scotch, I can state unequivocally, they have the best prime rib in all of Western... New York. I particularly like my rib bloody rare. It always shows up red in the middle and warm. Perfect every time. The staffare always so nice and willing to make your evening very enjoyable. When you ask for a drink , they don't make you wait, theyget it for you right away. We have been to many restaurants and this is my biggest issue. We will continue to dine at thescotch. We were especially thrilled when they brought back the salad bar, a tradition that went back many years. A great placeto dine, a special place to relax and enjoy a cocktail. Read more
Very solid restaurant for prime rib and steak. Disappointed that since the pandemic, the Salad bar is extra, but I do... understand. This place reminds of eating out with my parents when I was younger. Also burger loving son thinks they are greathere! Read more
Absolutely amazing place to eat! I'm forgetting our servers name, but on 06/20/22 at around 5pm, our server (male) was... absolutely perfect. I very rarely get that kind of service these days and he was very polite and on point. Will definitelyrecommend and can't wait to come back! Read more
Absolutely the best Steakhouse in WNY! The meal was spot on... and a totally enjoyable experience all the way around!
Service was excellent, soup de jour (soup of the day chicken noodle) was decadent, and the ambiance is good. Noise level is a 4.... hence the 2 stars. The bread they serve is dry and not warm, the Caesar salad is served with a brown Caesar dressing whichdoesn't taste right, and for $37 that NY strip should've been out of this world. Unfortunately, it was tough to chew and hadgristle in almost every bite and tasted churned. The curried rice was not good and the snap peas well I'm not a fan. Overallthis steakhouse has Ruth Chris prices and IHOP quality. I was not impressed. Read more
Dinner was good. I would have given 5 stars but my porkchops were a little under cooked near the bone. My friend said his steak... was delicious and cooked perfect. Next time I'll order steak at the steakhouse!! Read more
Food OK, restaurant is OK. First time I came here was almost 20 years ago, the food was great back then, well, thing has changed... now. The price is good like 20 years ago, very affordable. Came here for my mom birthday, nothing special...I guess this placeis just OK, not going to recommend people to come here. I do like the decorations and the old wood feeling, you can't find themin any steak house in NYC. Read more