Reviews for Peter's Diner in Amityville, NY
Good diner had good food and service but typical for these places. Nothing negative and nothing extra ordinery
Nice little diner. Pretty standard menu. I got breakfast. Very happy with my omelette. Home fries were really good too as were... the pancakes. Staff was very friendly. Place was clean. Will go back if I?m in the area. Read more
I stopped here for lunch after walking around Amityville and it was really good. I had a gyro platter and chicken soup and a... very friendly waitress. I think she said it was only her second day. Nice diner and I would definitely go back. Read more
the food was okay, lots of variety and decently good but I don?t think I would come back lol. The waiter was great, very kind... and helpful. The onion rings were amazing for some reason. The menu on here is outdated, prices have gone up 5$ per dish.Buffalo wings have no sauce on them but are very crunchy and tasty. Portion size is okay, nothing crazy. Read more
Great food. Prices comparable to most diners. Service is the best. Many servers are bilingual (English & Spanish) which is great... when you're out with friends who are more comfortable speaking Spanish. Read more
Nice little spot! Everything was delicious I had a patty melt and cream of turkey soup. Gear food very clean highly recommend!
Pete's is an Amityville institution and doesn't need this review, but I'm writing it anyway. I am convinced this diner's kitchen... is actually a portal to Narnia. There is simply no way a kitchen that small can turn a menu that big into perfect dish afterperfect dish that quickly, without access to some sort of Deep Magic. The staff are all courteous and thoughtful, and if you'rea regular, they'll never forget your coffee or tea preferences. Give them a visit, if you haven't already. This is a local dinerdone truly right. Read more
Good little diner. Nothing amazing or terrible. I would recommend sticking to diner breakfast/ brunch foods though.