Reviews for Angel Fired Pizza in Angel Fire, NM

This was a cool little place to eat. The service was great and so was the food. Wanted them again the next day for lunch but... they didn't open until 4pm. Must try it when visiting. Read more

We went on a Tues. afternoon when they opened at 4pm. Their Mediterranean pizza was SO excellent (crisp crust, great quality... cheese and very tasty toppings!). We enjoyed the La Cumbre Elevated IPA with great service and comfy, friendly vibe. Highlyrecommend, although unfortunately it does not have disabled access. Read more

Service was really slow because they had one server during Saturday evening dinner time. They forgot our appetizers and my... drink. Maybe a server called out or something, but unless you have more than hour it won't work. HOWEVER, the food wasabsolutely divine! That was some of the best pizza and fried ravioli I have ever eaten! The servers were friendly and apologizedfor the mistakes. The atmosphere was pretty good, too. We will definitely go back! Read more

Bar area awesome! Only 6 seat, but this is the best service! Great food and beer! Our family sat at table a different night, and... that took way too long. Get your orders togo, or sit at bar! They just don't have the staff right now. Read more

The pizza is fantastic and on par with any big city, they have great beers on tap from New Mexico (NM has some of the best... breweries in the U.S., yes CO and CA, NM has great, world class brewers), and the owners are wonderful people. Be patient; theyare short staffed, but it's worth the wait. They are really adding to the restaurant scene in Angel Fire and trying to be partof the community. Go hit the slopes or the trails and then come have a beer and a pizza with Angel Fire Pizza. Please notethat they just opened and took over from the old owners, so some other reviews may be from the different owners. Read more

We were celebrating the 4th of July weekend with our veteran family members in Angelfire. We stopped by to get a pizza here but... we needed separate checks. The waitress told us that that?s the worst thing you could do to a waitress and told us we will stillhave to pay automatic gratuity. Implying we were somehow splitting our ticket so we didn?t have to give a tip? She treated uslike we were some sort of riff raff. She threw our receipts on the table, brought some of our drinks, forgot the rest, threw acouple of straws on the table and took off. Worst service I ever received at any restaurant. As a former #1 pizza restaurantowner in a major city, from a taste perspective, the food was very bland and flavorless, the dough was thin like it should be abrick oven style pizza but it was floppy like it was undercooked in a conveyor oven. Their breadstick was burned to a crisp aswell. Not a good experience all around. The manager did credit some of our receipt because of the waitress?s behavior so hetried his best to make it right but the behavior of the waitress was unwarranted. We didn?t do anything but ask to split thecheck. Just say you can?t and we woulda figured out another way .. don?t have to be rude to us and treat us like trash. Itruined our meals. We were all holding in our anger trying not to blow up at the waitress and manager and stoop to her level. Bebetter, busy day, tough day, don?t take it out on random people. From the looks of some of the reviews, seems like it might be acommon occurrence .. Read more

I got pizza and wings To Go. Everything was as expected as with any business these days. Food was very good. They don't have 18... staff members to cater to your every beck and call. Expect decent service, good food, and friendly staff. Good indoor seatingarea (tho small) and if they were slammed full I wouldn't go here. Maybe order To Go or find another place. Lowe's market nextdoor, you can make yourself a bologna and cheese sandwich. Will def return Read more

Great experience despite reading some less happy reviews. We were greeted within < 5 mins & drink orders taken. Our waitress... was quick friendly & welcoming & we ordered both the small Cats Meow salad ( enough for 2) & the caprese pizza. Omg ?? so good. Cheese ,olive oil drizzled crust , tomatoes , prosciutto topped with a drizzle of balsamic vinegar. It was served hot & tastygalore ! Definitely will be making a return trip Read more