Reviews for Jersey Mike's Subs in Appleton, WI

This was my first time ever at a Jersey Mike's. I was very impressed by how quickly my order was taken and processed right in... front of me. They seem to make an extra effort with every single order. And the sandwich was excellent. I will definitely becoming back to New Jersey Mike's. Read more

HORRIBLE!!!!!! BREAD WAS I DONT KNOW HOW MANY DAYS OLD. ENDS ROCK HARD AND OUTER LAYER SHED WHILE EATING, STALE TASTE. THREW... MOST AWAY OF A $10 SANDWICH?TOO BAD IT WAS CARRY OUT AND LIVE PRETTY FAR AWAY. I WOULDNT GO BACK, IF YOU DO, I RECOMMEND DININGIN TO DEAL WITH YOUR SURPRISES THE MINUTE YOU OPEN THE SUB. Read more

Fast service and good food.

Really good subs, clean and friendly.

Friendly and quick staff. Very clean store. Have a place to eat at whenever I can make it back to Appleton next!

Decent service, but wow, I can't believe how poorly my sandwich was made. This is pathetic.

Greatest customer service friendly fast courteous sandwiches are awesome can't say enough good things about hear ????

Excellent service friendly employees. Great tasting sandwiches we got the #13 mikes way. Love this shop