Reviews for Great American Cookies in Appleton, WI

Their cookies are scrumptious and the large cookie cakes had very creative, intricate designs. Will definitely consider using... them for birthday parties or other special occasions. ???? Read more

I wish I could give 0 stars! First off they spelled his name wrong I had to go back and have them correct it. Them this just... looks absolutely horrible I took other pictures for comparison the mickey mouse is my cookie and the other ones are the displayones you can buy. Not happy at all for the price of these this looks terrible! Read more

Perfect Father?s Day gift from the kids!! So delicious????

I love these cookie joints.... And this one was really good the cookie was baked to perfection. Not hard or too soft and the... artwork on the cookies is very legible. Read more

got a custom design on a cookie cake and they did not disappoint! great quality and great design work. highly recommend.

I took my daughter and nephew to get cookies because my daughter loves theirs so much. I checked out and sat down nearby to eat... our dinner. One of the workers comes up to me and says excuse me I have your change. I didn?t need change I had paid exact. Hesays no, I made a mistake and forgot to charge you the buy 5 discount. This is your refund from that. I had no idea I qualifiedfor any sort of discount so I was already pleased with my service, but the admittance and time to go out of his way to correcthis mistake went a long way with me. Locally owned establishment which is nice to see. We will be back. Read more

Cookie cakes have been a tradition for our family and friends for many years. This little shop inside the mall does a great job... with service and quality of the cakes. Thanks for making many celebrations a little more sweet!! Read more

Spoke to Lauren today to order a cookie for my sons birthday and she was Amazing! Very friendly and helpful. Had a couple great... suggestions on decorating and keeping it fresh for a day. Thanks you so much Lauren! I am a customer service manager and i wastruly impressed! Read more