Reviews for Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub in Appleton, WI
Our 1st time Here and the food was awesome A pizza was Delicious My four-year-old daughter got spaghetti And finished before... everyone And she said it was super good Full bar Good fish tacos on Friday and all sorts of sandwiches restaurants Atmosphereand decorations are supremely cool The restaurant is dim And I liked it Read more
I don't know about these other reviews. Maybe they're used to Domino's or something. But their Pizza is amazing and Authentic... tasting and you can tell it's made w love. Service is also great and friendly always on top. Great atmosphere. I like the musicthey play , 80s which is a plus for me, I couldn't stay still...lol... Keep up the great work. Also gotta add those bonelesswings are to die for, best in the fox valley I would say. Read more
Nice atmosphere in this pub and pizzeria. Bar seating, booths, and tables available. Drinks and thin crust pizza were good. Food... is a little pricey. Read more
Not good pizza I tried there deep dish and hand tossed. The sauce has a lot of oregano in it and not good. The deep dish crust... taste like cardboard and is not Chicago style as they claim to be. The hand toss is no better. Cheap ingredients used in makingthe pizza for expensive prices. Small and medium pizza. Pickup. $45. They didn't seem busy when I walked in either. Read more
Horrible service. If I could give this place less than 1 star, I would. Good luck calling during ?business hours?, because they... won?t take your order. Called in for pick up an hour before closing and was greeted on the phone with nothing but rudeness. Wastold the kitchen was closed. So I Asked if I came in to order if I would be served and was met with silence on the other end.When I called back to speak to the manager she was condescending and rude and told me I was just ?having a bad day? and theyCOULD take my order. She didn?t apologize for the way the previous employee lied and handled the situation nor did she care. Idon?t even need to taste the food to know this plus sucks. I thought places wanted business?! Looks like they aren?t gettingmine! Read more
I grabbed a Chicago stuffed deep dish just because I had a taste for it. After researching the Appleton area, the best two were... Wiseguys and a place I will not mention. I chose Wiseguys because, let?s be honest, it?s a pretty cool name. The pizza was veryfresh as far as the ingredients. I had the spicy sausage and it was made pretty good. I was super pleased overall anddefinitely will be back. Read more
There's nothing worse then a bland pizza but that's Not what you'll get at Wiseguys pizza. Great zesty sauce. We really liked... the hand tossed pizza and in loved the stuffed pizza. I was really pleasantly surprised with this place . Read more
Great pizza and entrees. Menu has changed and gotten a little slim since COVID. What is on the menu is great.