Reviews for Dutchy's Pizza in Arcata, CA
Used to be a solid 5 star pizzeria. It's still good but the pizza is now a bit under baked (the extra crispy they used to do was... killer good) and they seemed to start skimping on toppings recently. Sad to see a place drop in quality. Read more
Best pizza in town easily. From the crust, to the sauce, the cheese and the toppings, all is top tier. This is the level of... pizza you would expect from NYC, and we are so lucky to have it here. Read more
Great pizza and barbecue chicken, place has character and worth the visit. Has two monitors showing sports, and has outdoor... seating. Read more
great vegan pizza options. Amazing crust. Dutchy himself came out to inform us that they were out of marinated garlic and we... wouldn't have the full margherita experience. He delivered the news as if he was telling us there were complications with aloved one's surgery. Very impressive service. Read more
Meh. We got a large veggie pizza for $30 and we were told to pick it up in an hour. I've had way better pizza for $20 and... faster. The best thing I got from there was the beer. The guy behind the counter seemed nice enough though and he was trying hisbest to keep up. He was courteous It did seem a little bit frazzled. Read more
Pizza is always on point. Delicious crust and toppings are epic! The specials run are decent priced as well. Dutchy is the... nicest guy to come from Jersey since the Boss! Thanks guys! Read more
One of the best pizzas I've had in a while. The crust was crispy and thin. Good amount of tomato sauce. The cheese melted... perfectly. Nice edge crust with some garlic butter I think. A great pizza. I got a little flustered over the difference betweena medium pizza and a 12-inch pizza. I learned there is no universal "small," "medium," "large" with pizza. A medium could bewhatever-inch the restaurant makes it. My social skills have declined in the last decade and more rapidly in the last fewyears. Dutchy's has a 12-inch and then a larger size (18-inch?). It's great pizza. The staff are friendly and helpful. I got ahalf cheese and half pepperoni. Read more
The pizza was good, not great, but SO EXPENSIVE for what you get. It also took me asking for my order to finally get it after 2... pizzas ordered after mine were taken. Read more