Reviews for Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Atascadero in Atascadero, CA
I was so disappointed with the BLT. Microwave bacon, thin as onion skin paper, lettuce that was wilted and stale, dry bread.... The potato salad however, was great. Read more
Oh. My. Goodness. The best Dutch Crunch bread I have ever had in my entire life. Just go.
This is one of my favorite places to get a sandwich in Atascadero. The prices are good. The services are quick and the... sandwiches are tasty. Read more
Delicious, fresh ingredients, and very flavorful. These sandwiches are beautiful. I think they are a great bread to ingredients... ratio. Will order from again and again. Very good. Read more
Standard build your own sandwich at the counter. It?s hard to mess up a sandwich, but they had some pretty funny signs. Also... they give you a free cookie. Read more
This place was fantastic. I guess it's a chain in CA but it hasn't gotten so large as to destroy itself. The food was very good.... We ordered a Reuben. a hot pastrami and an Italian and every single one was as good as I've ever had at any sandwich shop.Making a proper sandwich is about flavor balance and combination and these guys nailed it. They were friendly and the servicewas fast. The only option was taken out so we weren't able to dine in. Read more
Just as good as the one in SLO. What they get right is the bread. Most important part of a great sandwich. Can be cramped when... busy, but worth it if you can find a parking spot in the busy center. Read more
Love the food and the staff here sometimes they can mix up something in your Oder but most the time everything is perfect and... taste amazing Read more