Reviews for Johnny's New York Style Pizza in Atlanta, GA
The pizza & garlic knots are delicious. The lemon pepper wings are interesting. Not lemony but tasty.
The Stromboli was phenomenal - perfectly stuffed and ideally cooked. Delightful. Too bad service was lack-luster on a very slow... weekend afternoon. Read more
Buyer beware, the pizza is subpar and the service is even worse. The owners and management of this location should be ashamed of... the representation of the Johnny?s Pizza franchise.There is a hidden 18% gratuity on smaller parties (a group of four), in myopinion that is highly unprofessional. At the time of my visit, the added 18% gratuity was not posted anywhere in the restaurantor on the menu, nor was I, or a member of my group informed of the added charge. Also, at the time of my visit, we were notprovided a handheld menu, so we were unaware of the price changes and unusual higher prices. When I complained to the MOD, heinformed me that the 18% gratuity fee, ?doesn?t have to be posted?????? During our conversation, I came to the realization themanagement and staff are clearly in the wrong profession. I repeat: in my opinion, this location does not represent the Johnny?sPizza franchise! We ordered two small pizzas: The first pizza had 4 toppings and the second pizza had 2 toppings 1 small salad 3soft drinks 1 Blue-moon beer In conclusion the bill for a party of 4 (which included two minors) with a 2-way split check wasover 100.00. Read more
My boys used to love the food here especially the cheesecake. Now not so much. It doesn't taste the same. The cheesecake slice... used to be 4 times the size shown in the picture for $5.49. The price is the same but as you can see the cheesecake is not. Theydon't have a variety anymore either. This is not the Johnny's I remember. Read more
The food here is amazing! I had some of the best wings ever here with garlic knots and cheese ????.The atmosphere was relaxing... comfortable and inviting.the owners were more than welcoming. Wendel and Rollick thank you for a wonderful experience. Read more
I'm a truck driver, walked over from the pepsi plant about half a mile away, the pizza here not that great, far from a... traditional New York style also. I'm hoping the food is usually better, the atmosphere is nice, and it's nice to have a spot towalk to while being loaded. Read more
The outside looks inviting but not the inside. The pizza spoke volumes! It was delicious! We didn't like the crust but we are a... little biased with the pan crust. The cinnamon bite things tasted a little soapy by themselves but were soo good with the icingon top! Read more
As an Italian American I feel disrespected that our pizza was over cooked and the garlic knots were extremely dry. Really would... appreciate a refund honestly. Read more