Reviews for Johnny's New York Style Pizza in Atlanta, GA
The pizza, cheese, etc are overcooked with much dissatisfaction. This is third time using pizza establishment in the last six... months. The cost of large pizza with extra cheese and small caesar salad was $30.47. A recommendation is to ensure patronsreceive quality pizza, patrons should check food before leaving Johnny's. I would never had left store with excessive burntcheese when applicable e. There are holes in the from burnt cheese. Due to dissatisfaction, I tried on several times to callabout pizza for more than 10 minutes. Johnny is located on Cascade road near Fulton industrial Blvd. The store closes at 9pm. Read more
Great service. My first time here took my wife and kids. Very welcoming and friendly. Food was fantastic actually! I had the... Johnny deluxe my wife the buffalo sub babygirl had a slice of pepperoni. Garlic bread was good too. Definitely recommend.Doesn?t matter that the wait is 15+. They cook everything to order ! If you want excellent food go here. It?s worth the wait. Read more
Hands down the one of worse pizza spots I ever ate from in my life. I would have been better off with chuckie cheese pizza.... Couldn't get pass the first slice and tossed it. This place says they make NYC style pizza but this has to be a joke. Read more
Took 5 min to even be acknowledged standing at the register. 10 total to order 2 pieces and a tea. 30 + min to get everything... all at once. It is undoubtedly the dryest, most overcooked and yet COLD! pizza I've ever had. Reminds me of my ex.... Will notbe coming back here. Read more
Soo. . . I?m starting to wonder if this place is just a front. They?re regularly out of essentials - like pizza - and they... frequently have order mistakes. Tonight we ordered Caesar salad with our pizza. It?s just a bunch of SPINACH leaves under waytoo much Parmesan. Like, WHAT???? They used to be so good too! Read more
Horrible. The server was great but overall other staff was not on task. Laughing, giggling,loud and not having a care in the... world. We got there at 118p.m. didn't get acknowledged until 131p.m. and order was taken at 142p.m. Food finally came at 224p.m.and then the food was burnt and nasty. Cook got mad because we requested a manager and didn't want to remake the food. Overdisgusted and still very hungry. I always loved Johnny's but also always goes to Virginia Highland Cobb County location. I onlychose this because it's right by my house but never will I chose this location again. Need to upgrade within restaurant andtrained staffed. Read more
(This review was involuntarily sponsored by Johnny's New York Style Pizza) This morning I heard a knock on my door. I thought... it was my neighbor and i didn't answer because my house wasn't clean. About 20 minutes later, I leave to run some errands and Ifind a pizza from this restaurant on my doorstep. I decided to eat it and leave a review. In fairness, the pizza was sittingoutside in the cold for 20+ minutes before I got to it. I ate one slice. The sauce is uninspired. It tastes like a mixture oftomato paste and oregano. The crust is pretty good, it's thin and the crust has a nice crunch. The toppings are also ofserviceable quality. I am, however, disappointed by the amount of (or lack of) cheese on this pizza. Most of the cheese is in apile on the center, and even there, it's a pretty thin layer. It doesn't even go all the way to the crust, nor do the toppings.There is a ring of dried-up sauce about 2" up to the crust. This pizza will not give you the cheese pull photo you need forInstagram. I can't offer an opinion on their prices, as again, I did not pay for this pizza. I've given this pizza 3/5 stars,which takes into consideration the fact that it sat out in the cold for 20 minutes, and the fact that it was free. Read more
I?m very disappointed. Do you know how much I paid for a pizza I couldn?t eat? I am not coming back. I was on my lunch break I... didn?t have time to com back in person so I called several times no answer then when someone answered they hung the phone when Iwas try explain to them that I just wanted a new pizza. I understand mistakes happen but this restaurant continues to make pizzalike this. I am not coming back ever!!! Read more