Reviews for Tony Boloney's Atlantic City in Atlantic City, NJ

Had someone who wanted 'good' pizza. Everyone I asked kept saying 'go to Tony's'. So we went. It's behind the Ocean casino,... looks like a house. So you'll go right past it if you're not paying attention. They actually have a good selection of specialtypizzas as well as some other offerings. They sell their sauces, olive oil, and others spreads and even T-shirts. We tried a fewdifferent pies, love the moonshiner. Kind of like a margarita only better. Pepperoni pizza was really good but very flavorfulold world pepperoni. Turned out to be a very nice treat! Read more

Absolutely lovely place to have an awesome pizza! The staff is very kind! The refillable cup saved my life. Pizzas have a good... price considering how good they are. They have air conditioning. Read more

I am sad writing this review. We visit ac on a yearly basis and always look fwd to Tony Bolonis. This time around they had... workers that barely understood me and their pizza significantly declined. I am grateful I only got a slice which was completelyburnt. Not my fav spot to visit anymore when visiting ac. Read more

If I could give it no stars I would. I was making fun of a guy who was being a Karen complaining about the wait time upon my... arrival. Boy was he right! Place was slow, overpriced and dirty. Ordered two slices. Cold and not very flavorful. At almost $5per slice for pepperoni pizza we were highly disappointing. We also ordered 10 wings and a piece of garlic bread. After tiptotal was $52 dollars. Unreal now that I think about it. Went to wash my hands after I was done eating. Hit with the strongscent of piss and a sticky floor. Stay away from this place looks great on social media but overprice, dirty and slow serviceit’s not worth it! Side note fountain soda flat AF! Read more

We have had Tony Boloney's from one or two other locations in the past. However, something about this place definitely made it... feel more local / original. It could be that the location is just less glamorous, more gritty and more in-tune /representative of AC. There is not only the AC themed graffiti outside but also an AC themed mural inside as well as whatappears to be an AC original art piece along the other wall. It is a small place with only 4 or 5 tables good for 4 people maxat each table for indoor seating. As far as the pizza goes, it seemed true to form. It is hell of greasy but definitelyenjoyable. We had the original cheese, the pinky (pepperoni) and sh*#faced (basically BBQ chicken and other ingredients). Thatlast one was really good. Definitely worth a try. Read more

Upon entering, the aroma of deliciousness is more than appetizing as it greets You at the door. In photo is the King Louis and... the Lobsta Roll Pie. The Lobsta Roll pie is a special kind of tasteful. Meanwhile, the King Louis is just like your favoriteFrench onion soup made into a pizza. Very clean facility. Read more

I lovedddddddd this pizza. Crazy thing is that I ordered from them online on Gold Belly and my kids loved it. So while traveling... during Spring Break '21 we decided to stop in and give them another try and boyy what a treat! Their pizza selections are crazyand delicious. Love the fact that their sauce isn't too thick also. I could truly go on & on but I encourage you to try themfor yourself. Read more

First time at this place. Couldn't resist the name is fabulous ???? Dude running the cash register is really helpful. Nice... people and good food. A recommended visit when in AC. Note: It is helpful to place your order prior to getting there because theplace will have a line for sure...why you ask? Because it's good. Try it out???? Read more