Reviews for Amato's Sandwich Shops in Augusta, ME
HANDS DOWN the best pizza I?ve ever had in Maine!!! Don?t take my word for it try it yourself!! Good prices wonderful customer... service I will come again :) Read more
August 26, 2022- I like their meat stuffers so one day I got home and took a few bites and something was starting to form on the... back of my teeth. It was parchment paper. I called a couple days later due to work to inform of what happened. The managerdidn't believe me so I told her I'll come down with a picture (which is parchment in my hand). After she confirmed it was anddont understand how. She made me 6 free herself. I thanked her and went home happy but I took one bit and BAM! Parchment paperwhich is the picture of the plate. I called Amato's late afternoon again and spoke with Ms. Manager because I wanted to informher it happened again and to watch out for the other customers that will order this item. I feel she was getting irritated withme trying to figure out why/how I was eating parchment paper. She said sorry then hung up. I forgot to mention to her that itwas the pepperoni. However it was cut parchment stuck to the outside the cooked with the item. I didn't call back due to Ms.Manager not sounding like she wanted to resolve the situation. So sorry for whoever got meat stuffers. I won't be ordering fromthere again. Read more
Calzone was cooked to perfection and super cheesy. Just the way I like it. Wish they had lays salt and vinegar chips though... because the Utz brand doesn't go as heavy on the flavor, but I'm not going to fault the company for that as they don't cookthem. Read more
For the third time, I place an order for a calzone. 20-25 minutes they tell me. I get there 25 minutes in, pay, and they are... still assembling the calzone. I sit and wait, getting all hangry. And I wait some more, 20 additional minutes more. I finallyget up and look to see my calzone order is sitting up on the pizza oven, who knows for how long. Amatos, you've killed my lunchbreak three different times, why do I have to do your job to see if my order is done. You can do better. Read more
we got a pizza and a sandwich. they were both excellent! the wait wasn't long, though we opted to eat in our car, as it was far... too warm inside the shop to eat. Read more
Mmmmm so good! I had to get the original. We make these at home since I live in Ohio and Amato's is not an option. It had been... at least 30 years since I had one and it was just like I remembered! Only 4 stars because even though thr service was quick shedidn't advise if drinks came with my sandwich and I didn't see prices for the drinks. Read more
First time at Amato's, and it won't be the last. For breakfast, I wanted an egg and cheese muffin with sausage and peppers.... Asked if possible as it wasn't on the menu. Within a few minutes I had a delicious muffin with filled with an egg, creamycheese, peppers and onion. YUMMY! Thank you Omar for your friendly welcome and for sharing a bit about Amato's history. Reallyenjoyed my first visit, looking forward to trying their other menu options as well as getting that muffin again. Read more
Great pizza. Delicious crust and the sauce is really good. Asked for it well done and it was perfect. Really appreciate a great... pizza place and this is one. Read more