Reviews for Mulberry Street Babylon in Babylon, NY
One of my two favorite pizza places in the area. I get pizza here multiple times a month. The regular cheese pie is fantastic... but where they really shine is all of the specialty slices. I often get a salad slice but there's so many options I've beentrying them all and haven't found one that wasn't amazing. I highly recommend this place if you're considering it. Absolutelytop-notch pizza. Read more
Great pizza slices . Great dessert. Big selection of pizza and sandwiches.
$10 for a Stromboli the size of my hand. $8 for two slices of regular pizza and they charge you for a side of sauce. Also very... difficult to order unless you speak Spanish. Bathrooms smell moldy. Would not recommend. Pizza was mediocre at best Read more
This is a great place. We did take out, didn't eat in. But their menu is extensive, with lots of items you do not normally see.... Fresh pastas, an appetizer egg roll filled with meatball, sausage, pepperoni and mozzarella (unbelievably good), and much more.We all got dinners, and beside the appetizer a large cheese pie. Everything was delicious, and the pie was outstanding. I trulyrecommend this restaurant. We will definitely be going here again (and again). Read more
Went for dinner with two other people, their order arrived first, made no sense to wait for me, their food would get cold. They... finished, now mine arrived, so they had to watch me eat alone. Not satisfied, I took it home, it wasn't the greatest pizza. Youwould think a party of three would get their food within minutes of each other, not fifteen minutes apart, ruined for me thewhole experience. Taking orders and coordinating meals is a skill that Mullbury is lacking. Read more
Tonight was our first night here. I saw the wine and dine special for Friday evening which included two entrees and a bottle of... wine for $60 on Friday nights. We live in Nassau but figured what the heck, this sounds good. It was certainly worth the drive.Our waitress Peggy was very welcoming & friendly. They bring a nice Bread Basket to the table prior to your meal which included3 different types of bread. I ordered the eggplant spinach rollatini with penne pasta and my husband ordered the chickenrollatini marinara with penne which had spinach as well. Both meals were huge and absolutely delicious. We both took half home.We got a bottle of Pinot Grigio which was a full size bottle and it was great. We will definitely be back. They also have Mondaynight pasta specials and Tuesday night chicken specials which you can see on their website and for very reasonable prices. Itwas a clean, quiet dining room and and all covid protocols were in place. The front entrance of the restaurant is a pizza parlorwith a ton of different style pizzas you can take to go or have delivered. Read more
Service was excellent. Our waitress was extremely friendly and attentive. So many options on the menu, I wanted to try... everything. I ordered the chicken parm, it was a little dry but overall the food was enjoyable. Read more
I'm conflicted because I love the food, but yesterday I ordered a chicken roll. The server acknowledged that it fell, apologized... and put another one in the oven. Guess what he did with the one that fell on the floor ?!!! He put it right back on the serviceplate for another customer to chose it. That makes me question the health and sanitary protocols of this place. Such a shamebecause it really has delicious food- but I definitely don't want to eat from a place that would serve food that fell on thefloor. Beware. Read more