Reviews for Post Office Café in Babylon, NY
I had my baby shower at the Post Office Cafe this past weekend & everything was amazing! The room is beautiful, service was... great, & food was delicious! I especially want to thank and shout out managers Chris & Melissa. Melissa was so helpful inbooking & planning the room set-up for the day of. Chris was there the day of and was great, too! What was even better was howthey treated us after the event. Long story short, some of our gifts were thrown away (no fault of theirs - 1000% our fault). Ididn’t realize until the next day that I was missing gifts & when I called them freaking out, they were so thorough in helpingus check & even came outside to the garbage to help us find the bag! They both truly went above and beyond giving us gloves andthey even went as far as getting in the garbage to pull out some of our items for us. I wasn’t expecting this much help,especially for something that wasn’t their fault - they truly went above and beyond and were SO nice about it! Read more
My mom and friends planned my Bridal Shower here this past weekend and the Post Office Cafe (and my friends and mother!)... absolutely NAILED IT! The vibes were immaculate, the server and bartender were kind and professional and the food wasdelicious! They were so accommodating. I would absolutely recommend this place for anyone wondering if they should have a partyhere :). ! Thank you. Read more
My sister and I took my Dad here for his birthday. Our waitress was so welcoming. We got the Bang Bang Shrimp Tacos, Buddha... Bowl with Salmon, and Roast Beef French Dip. Everything was AMAZING!! I didn't get a picture of the French Dip (my Dad wasalready teasing me for taking a picture of the food lol). I will definitely be bringing my husband back here for a date night Read more
Pleasantly surprised at the dining area off the side of the main dining area. Very clean and very quiet. I was able to watch... the football game today while eating The waitress took our order very promptly we received drinks quickly and got ourappetizer within 5 minutes. The spinach artichoke dip was superb. Ordered the fish and chips. The chips were actually frieswhich tasted good. 3 large pieces of fried fish were given copious amount of Cole slaw and tartar sauce. The fish was cookedwell, however, lacked seasonings. The waitress, Gina was very accommodating throughout the meal, excellent service Read more
This place is so much better than it was years ago. The food is better, the service is better. Everything I tried on the menu... has been great. The ppl that work here are awesome. I will be going back on a regular basis. Read more
Great dinner! We go to the library cafe in Farmingdale often, and this is very similar (same owner group). The spinach dip was... great (I always love when it comes with both warm pita and chips). The fish and chips was good too. Our server was very friendlyand attentive. My personal opinion was that it was better than library, but my husband says he still likes library better butyou can't go wrong with either. I also found it to be particularly clean and bright thanks to the sky lights. Read more
A very good dining experience with a nice staff and delicious food. Our waitress Devin was wonderful and helpful, as was the... rest of the staff. I enjoyed my cocktail, Cole slaw and chicken sandwich on lettuce. My dad liked his Smoked BBQ Burger, SweetPotato Fries and Gin & Tonic. My wife enjoyed her Shrimp Tacos a Malibu Bay Breeze. Overall, worth a visit. Read more
Booked a private party for my daughter's 1st birthday. The space had a good layout. The food and service were great for the most... part. Couldn't have asked for a better place to celebrate. It was intimate and the champagne punch was refreshing. Shawn was ourwaiter from beginning to end, he was there taking care of us along with Jenna. Only wish we had more time to setup beforehand. Read more