Reviews for The Islander in Bainbridge Island, WA

I love their lobster bisque. Steak and lobster dinner for 2 was wonderful. Our waitress was fun and fast. We can't wait to come... back. Read more

Excellent steak, lobster, and drinks! Really enjoyed the Caesar salad as well. Definitely will be back!

Very nice and quiet place. Amazing staff, amazing good and amazing ambiance. Their tomahawk steak is phenomenal! Definitely on... our top 5 steak house. Best bang for your buck! We will definitely come back! Worth the drive! Read more

Wow! What a pleasant surprise to discover this island gem! Based on another review, we stopped in and enjoyed a couple of... well-crafted drinks. My guy enjoyed the fish & chips, and I thoroughly enjoyed the lobster bisque! The Caesar salad wasperfectly assembled with large slivers of fresh Parmesan and a garlicky dressing. We loved the vibe, service, and food/drinks.Chestin is a master at his craft of cocktails, and Kristy provided friendly and great service. We can?t wait to try the steaknext time or maybe the cauliflower ?steak? with a red pepper sauce. My new island fav hole in the wall! Read more

We had such a great experience! I had the best old fashioned I've ever had! the food was absolutely amazing! Justin , the... experience was wonderful and your sister was the bing cherry on top! Read more

Knows exactly what it's about, and doesn't care what you think it should be. Got to the front door and thought I was in the... wrong place, because it didn't necessarily look the part, but double checked and went in. Staff was incredibly friendly andhelpful. The food was phenomenal. I had a filet mignon and it was exceptional and paired excellently with the scotch the waiterrecommended. My girlfriend had the lobster and said it was probably the best lobster she'd ever had. Will almost certainly becoming back. Update: April 2022 Still one of our favorite places we've been. The food was again to die for. Girlfriend had afew bartender's choice cocktails that she was very pleased with and I was recommended a new favorite scotch. The cake was agreat way to end the meal, we ended up both needing our own slice. Staff is still incredibly fun and helpful. We're thinking ofmaking it a thing to come a few times a year even though we're from across the water. Meant to take more pictures, but forgotcause we were having such a lovely time. Read more

Everything we had was delicious. The staff were friendly and efficient. Recommend reservation as there aren't many tables.

Visiting Bainbridge Island and found this restaurant in a random google search. We stopped by on a Friday night and had one of... the best meals I?ve had in a long time. The vegetables were fresh and cooked perfectly, the mashed potatoes were delicious, thefrites were crispy, the ribeye was cooked perfectly and the lamb was so amazing I actually chewed on one of the bones! Greatservice and nice ambiance. Seriously, stop by, you won?t be disappointed! Read more