Reviews for Our Table American Bistro in Bargersville, IN

I was very impressed with all the attention to detail. The vegetables and garnishes on our food were my favorite part! The... hummus appetizer was amazing. My least favorite was probably the pork chop. I'm not really a big meat person, so I probablyshould have ordered something with less meat, like maybe the lasagna. I almost ordered that. ???? plus I asked for a steakknife and the server forgot. So I had to use my butter knife and it was kind of hard to cut through. Not sure if it was cookedright since I've read other reviews that said they could cut their pork chop with a spoon. I'm totally willing to go back andtry again, though. Read more

We had a delicious meal at Our Table! Very cozy and laid back environment. Everything we ordered was hot, fresh and great... tasting! We will be back for sure! Read more

The drive to Beautiful Bargersville was nice the night was perfect. Plenty of parking. We did have reservations had to wait... about 10 minutes to be seated. The inside was very Quaint, and clean the bar was very cool we were seated in the party wine roomwe could see into the bakery where everything is baked fresh daily. There was a fire going in the fire place. It was a littlepricey for a family of 4. So this was a treat. Our server was Georgia she was very knowledgeable explaining the special of thenight as well as everything on the menu. Our food was brought out by Trent he was very polite and it showed he loved what he wasdoing he was very kind even brought us fresh bread. The food was delicious the chef is top notch. Then came the deserts. Theywere wonderful we each got something different so that we could try several. This restaurant is a five star ?? I give it a 10for sure. Will be back. Service was Fantastic! Read more

Excellent service! The server told us seafood is flown in fresh daily. Had the scallops and shrimp special, cooked perfectly!... Very flavorful. Fresh baked bread was great too. Others at our table had the thin sliced filet sandwiches and raved about themelt in your mouth steak. And the fresh salmon was buttery with a crisp exterior. We also had a Caesar salad, whichunfortunately was not good. It was wet and I didn?t care for the flavor, just a bad salad. That aside, everything else wasfantastic and we?ll be back again. Read more

The experience we had last night for our anniversary was nothing short of the best dining experience we?ve ever had. It... surpassed every high-end steak house we?ve ever visited. Our waitress was kind and attentive, our drink orders were quick andstrong, the gentleman that brought out our food from the kitchen was extremely nice, and the list goes on. We received apersonalized card from the chef for our anniversary thanking us for dining with them and a small desert on the house for theoccasion. The food was outstanding in presentation. The shrimp Diablo pasta was to die for. Unbelievable vodka sauce. The steakwas great. Tender and cooked to a wall to wall medium rare. I really cannot say enough good things about this place. Read more

1st time here, we wanted to try something new; more upscale but local. My wife and I celebrated our 5th anniversary. I left a... note for the staff and told them ahead of time and they really delivered! Everyone acknowledged our celebration, they had a cardfrom the management and chef with some macaroons. We enjoyed great wine, crisp cocktails and amazing food. I had the beeftenderloin sliders - I always go for these if a chef is willing to put them on a menu with great entree dishes. They werestellar, I ordered mine medium rare and they were perfect! Shaved and served with a great sauce and fries. My wife had thesalmon and was truly impressed. We finished with the crème brûlée and I have to tell you, it was on point (maybe the bestI?ve had). We?ll be coming back, we appreciated the staff going the extra mile to make our special night ever better. It?s a nobrained 5 star - give it a try! Service level is truly unmatched. Read more

We made reservations to try this place which is odd for a newer restaurant, but now we see why. We ordered the Cajun fries which... were fantastic. My husband had the pork chop with bacon kraut and though he doesn't like sauerkraut, the waitress talked himinto trying it and he was so glad he did since it doesn't really taste anything like he expected. I had the shrimp bucatinidiablo which was also fabulous. He ordered apple pie and ice cream and I had creme brulee for dessert. The presentation of thefood was definitely well thought and reminds me of something you'd get downtown. I'm glad we've got a place like this on thesouthside now Read more

Totally blown away with everything about this restaurant!!! I dine many times a year at many places and it was totally... fantastic!!! The drinks, appetizers, entrees and especially the dessert. I would highly recommend it will not disappoint. Wecannot wait to go back Read more